Friday, April 04, 2008
Mordecai Kaplan and Louis Ginzberg discuss the relative merits of derashas vs ancient (and modern) laundry lists
Monday, March 31, 2008
R. Nathan Marcus Adler's instructions for his family
Here are some interesting excerpts and summaries of his Last Will & Testament written for his descendants on "December 31, 5644 - 1883." The matters discussed here shed valuable light on his own priorities as well as what rabbinic concerns within Britain were at the time. His words alone are in inverted commas.
"I have been very ill and near death, but Almighty God in His mercy has so far restored me to health that I am able, although inadequately, to write. Being in Brighton, and no longer surrounded by members of my family, I feel bound to lay the following religious duties to the hearts of my children, grand- and great-grandchildren, with the earnest wish that they may always observe them, and thereby keep my memory fresh and green."
Adler goes on to explain why it may seem that he will speak less of "moral duties" than "religious duties." It is not because the former are less important - on the contrary, they are also mitzvos and thus commanded by God. However, in his time there is a greater spirit of laxity in the aforementiones religious duties, and therefore his family faces a greater temptation to neglect them. Adler then writes that the main principle of Judaism is conained in Deut 6. They must always remember "ushmartem va'asitem," (Lev.19.37).
Next Adler explains that Tanakh, our Bible, is our most precious book, because it "affords us guidance through life," and also "it teaches Israel his origin, his history, his mission to influence mankind in the knowledge of the only one God." Furthermore, it introduces the concept of the eventual arrival of the moshiach, when the whole world will know the one God. Given how important Tanakh is, Adler councils his family, cause your children to read one perek daily, perhaps after morning prayer.
Having mentioned the centrality of Tanakh, he then stresses the importance of Torah she-be-'el peh - Oral Law - giving by way of illustration the examples of tefillin and mezuzah. Then he asks them to read the weekly sidra with targum ("or an easy commentary"), or even with English translation should his descendants not know Hebrew sufficiently. (Interestingly, he does not stress the importance of Hebrew proficiency. Perhaps these are the words of a man resigned to the fact that not all of his descendants could be counted upon to know Hebrew. It should be remarked that Adler was party to the establishment of a society for the promotion of the revival of Hebrew, spearheaded by Eliezer Lipmman Silbermann, editor and founder of Ha-maggid.) Also - study rabbinical literature so that they would be acquainted with it - at the very least, on shabbat.
Next Adler turns to the home, which he says is the most important Jewish institution and the center of Jewish life. Parents must keep kashrut with rigor and they must teach their children to keep it just as strictly outside of the home. The wife must take care that nothing trefa enters the premises and - interesting! - she should not be ashamed to involve herself in the kitchen to ensure that the servants are keeping kashrut, especially basar ve-chalav (ie, the separation of meat and dairy).
"Do not listen, my dear children, as regards the Law 'Thou shall not seethe a kid in its mother's milk' (Ex. 23.19, 34.26, Deut. 14.21), to the criticism of the so-called Neologians (ie, Reformers. 'Neolog' was the term current among Hungarian Jewry. In Reform in general, but especially in Britian, there was a decided neo-Karaite tendency), who assert that the Law must be taken literally, for this would be senseless. Depend upon it, from the very time of its promulgation it was expounded and carried out in its extended sense." Adler emphasizes that the threefold repetition in the Bible teaches us to keep it scrupulously - "Depend upon it."
Furthermore, they should know that there are also the commandments called chukim, for which we do not know a reason for its command, whether such a reason is "spiritual, moral or sanitary or all three together" - but we do know that no mitzvah is without beneficient motive.
Next he discusses behavior for all week long: integrity and scrupulousness in business is a must. He reminds them that such behavior will give them a good name and make their reputation, but above all, it will constitute a kiddush Ha-shem.
He then tells them forcefully: shun usury! "Whatever your calling, shun, oh my dear ones, every kind of usury, for usury still constitutes, alas! the malignant canker which sullies the fair name of our nation."
Moving away from the week, he tells them that as industrious as they must be during the week, they must rest and keep the shabbat. The shabbat teaches the greatest truths of Judaism. It has been "the cause and moving spirit of Israel's preservation." (Ahad Ha'am may have coined the clever phrase that the Sabbath kept the Jews even more than the Jews kept the Sabbath, but you can see that the sentiment predated that.) What should their shabbat be like? It should be joyous, a day of joy and tranquility. They must "distinguish it with a better meal, better dress" and with exercise in the fresh air, but above all a "higher rest," which sanctifies God's name.
Although he already mentioned that they ought to study the sidra with Targum and also rabbinic literature, he reemphasizes this point. On shabbat they must show an even greater devotion to and more zealous study of Torah (than, presumably, during the week). He suggests that on the shabbat they give their children examinations to see how they've advanced in their Torah study.
What else mus they do for shabbat? They must keep shabbat holy - from beginning to end. There must be no business, writing or riding - no matter how early shabbat begins (presumably here we see that a tendency toward laxity with the beginning of shabbat, when it started early during winter, was rampant). Adler reminds his family to remember Neh. 13.15-23, wherein the profanation of the beginning of shabbat brought about great evil.
He assures them that if they lead a pious life, they could expect to escape the punishments which God warned sinners of, and they will instead partake of the choice blessings that he promised the individual and the nation. They can be assured that they will enjoy this world and the world to come. שֹׂבַע שְׂמָחוֹת, אֶת-פָּנֶיךָ; נְעִמוֹת בִּימִינְךָ נֶצַח - forevermore!" (Ps. 16.11)
He concludes "Most solemnly" that they are to "be good Jews and Jewesses," and are to keep in mind future reward and punishment, to lead a life of firm morality and strict observance!
I obtained the text of R. Nathan Marcus Adler's will from Ethical Wills: A Modern Jewish Treasury, by Jack Riemer and Nathaniel Stampfer.
Further reading, see the interesting tribute "The Late Chief Rabbi, Dr. N. M. Adler זצ״ל," by M. Friedländer in JQR Vol. 2, No. 4. (Jul., 1890), pp. 369-385.
1 It should be noted that he pioneered an interesting technique for asserting his rabbinic authority: he all but banned other rabbis from operating as such in Great Britain. To such an extent did he personally enjoy hegemony over the rabbinate in Britain, that dayyanim serving under him were unable to even use the title "rabbi," - when they were being called to the Torah or otherwise!
Thursday, March 20, 2008
Rabbi Chid"a and chocolate
"We departed from Nice at noon . . . and crossed two mountains and a hill . . . we came upon a mountain with such deep snow that we could even stand; us and all of our things sank into the snow. So we hired four gentiles to assist us . . . It was a sunny day and I was wearing two samaras2 and two pairs of socks, but even so I was in great distress from the cold. It was a good thing I had chocolate with me - I ate more than a litre!

1 The title is from Proverbs 2.9.
2 Spanish sheepskin coats
Monday, March 17, 2008
Can a woman be מדקדק?
One must recite the Kerias Shema with cantillation, as the Torah is read. Rema's addendum: But this isn't customary in our [Ashkenazi] countries. Nevertheless, the grammatically-inclined are stringent in this matter.
Here is a typical example of Kerias Shema as found in Artscroll siddurim ("Everyone should have a copy").

(click above to enlarge or click here)
But here is the Kerias Shema as found in the Artscroll Ohel Sarah Woman's Siddur, where the cantillation is not included "for the convenience of those who recite in the manner it is read from the Torah":

Interestingly enough, in the Artscroll "chinuch edition" siddur (Chaim Shlomo) for schoolchildren the cantillation is present (without the note explaining why there is cantillation).
Hat tip goes to Moshi.
Thursday, March 13, 2008
What's peshat with peshat? Is there a place for peshat in Orthodoxy?
He writes:
"WADR, if one would read the list of topics, one would think that Pshat and the academic study of Tanach, as defined and severely critiqued by R Moshe Lichtenstein are the only or preferred means of Parshanut HaMikra. Like it or not, Rashi and Ramban both spend much time delineating what is Pshat, Drush and which Medrash is worth considering and which is far fetched from the Pshat. Ibn Ezra cites but also for the most part vehemently rejects Karaite based interpretations. It is too bad that noone is on the listof speakers who can deal with the issues of the borderline between Pshat and Drash."
...
"FWIW, the Abarbanel is very critical of Ibn Ezra's intimation that Joshua Bin Nun wrote part of the Torah ( Bamidbar 21:1)."
To which I reply:
"The homiletic style is sovereign within Orthdoxy right now (as partially evidenced by your fine parasha roundups), with peshat being almost considered illegitimate these days.Thus, a better critique would be for the drush establishment to integrate some peshat a bit more, rather than for some solitary occasions like this one, which are trying to return peshat to a legitimate endeavor within Orthodoxy, to be asked to integrate homiletics. Homiletics is strong, now let's support peshat too."
and I ask:
"Will you cherry pick to find commentators who are critical of Abarbanel's unorthodoxies? Or to criticize the Gemara's intimation that Yehoshua wrote part of the Torah?It isn't the Orthodox exegetical establishment that is beleaguered, within Orthodoxy, these days. My recommendation is to allow Ibn Ezra and Neo-peshat some space to function within Orthodoxy, if not for their own intrinsic value, then at least so that the part of our community which is incapable of being edified by gematriah and farfetched non-literal explanations can also be edified by the study of Tanakh."
* And here for the list of speakers and topics.
Wednesday, March 05, 2008
The הברה אשכנזית in a 17th century English book
Have a look at the spelling of the word לילית in the following from the book The present state of the Jews by Lancelot Addison, London 1675:


Sunday, March 02, 2008
To think that I shall never see,
A Poem lovely as a . . .19th century Hebrew forgery scandal
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Jerome's Hebrew
I posted a comment in the Lieberman post directly below this, and I liked the way I brought out my point, so it's becoming its own post. It concerns Jerome.
Shmuel noted that Jerome "actually did know some Hebrew, having lived in Israel and who was tutored by a local Jew in the Hebrew language and the Tanach." I wanted to broaden that, and acknowledge that Jerome's Hebraic knowledge did exceed the way that sounded, despite the fact that he is cut down as a Hebrew authority by the Jewish Encyclopedia's (1906) thorough entry on him (link, saying that his "knowledge of Hebrew is considerable only when compared with that of the other Church Fathers and of the general Christian public of his time. His knowledge was really very defective. Although he pretends to have complete command of Hebrew and proudly calls himself a "trilinguis" (being conversant with Latin, Greek, and Hebrew), he did not, in spite of all his hard work, attain to the proficiency of his simple Jewish teachers."
However, keeping in mind Shmuel's statement that he "knew some Hebrew," I say: He knew more than some Hebrew. He knew Hebrew well, not only having lived in Israel, not only having been tutored in Hebrew (and Jewish interpretations) by JewS, but I know he knew Hebrew well also because he translated the Bible into Latin from Hebrew. Whether or not the Vulgata is the *best* translation ever it is no mean feat to translate the entire Tanakh from Hebrew. (As it happens, it is pretty good, although it naturally also Christological, which makes it Christo-midrashic rather than always literal or peshat oriented.)
Doing only a reasonable job on a translation is impossible without knowing Hebrew well. It is not like today where you can sit down with a stack of translations, Hebrew dictionaries, concordances and references, and so in theory someone who only knows the slightest amount of Hebrew could pretend to make a translation, and perhaps pass it off as something original and even "reasonable." Jerome was working from scratch. He was also an exegete, and he wrote quite a bit about the Hebrew language itself. (Incidentally, he knew Punic, which is cognate with Hebrew. Since he engaged in a little bit of comparative linguistics, I suppose his knowledge of that language helped him. He was no stranger to the tongues of the Shemites, Hebrew included.)
When one considers that the science of Hebrew grammar had barely developed yet, if at all - and that meant that knowledge of Hebrew was achieved through intensive steeping in the texts of that language, nurturing a good intuition and feel for the language - fluency probably would have been achieved in an almost osmosis-like fashion. And how was that done? It would have meant a classic rabbinic education of the time. He therefore did knew Hebrew well.
Jerome achieved what he did in the language (including being able to describe it with sometimes excellent insights) without being, essentially, a צורבא מרבנן.
Monday, February 25, 2008
R. Saul Lieberman on being historical: tikkunei soferim and not conflating ancient with modern sensibilites
"Jacob Reifmann collected a great number of Biblical passages which contain rougher expressions than many of those included among the corrections of the Soferim. Why then, he asks, did the Soferim (or the verse) modify some utterances while they left others unchanged? Why the inconsistency."
"However, we cannot apply our modern standards to the ancients. We are not in a position to measure their sensitivity to certain expressions and their definition of rudeness of style. We really find no consistency in the use of euphemisms even in later rabbinic literature. We are in no position to judge the ancients for their seeming inconsistency; they were guided by their own standards and reasons. We must also take the individuals, times and places into consideration."
Thursday, February 21, 2008
A wedding poem in honor of Ramchal and Mrs. Luzzatto, with non-pc imagery
Here is a description:
The wedding poems, or epithalamia, in The Jewish Theological Seminary's collection date from the 17th - 20th centuries. They are written in Italian, German or Hebrew in verses praising the bride and bridegroom and praying for their prosperity. Designed primarily as celebratory poems praising the newlyweds and their families, Jewish epithalamia are characterized by a common structure. An introduction consisting of honorific statements introduces the names of the groom and his father. Frequently, the bride and her lineage are also noted. In the central section the author presents the poem itself employing any one of a variety of literary formats. The third section usually consists of the author's final salutations and a signature, using either the poet's full name or initials. While many of the poems are printed, the few handwritten examples that remain attest to the personal nature of such verses.
The following is one such poem from 1730, in honor of the wedding of Moshe Chaim Luzzatto to Zipporah Finzi (by Raffaele Haim D’Italia).

Even if this charming custom were to reappear, I doubt the nude cherubs would prove a popular stationary choice these days.
Be sure to check out the JTS Digital Collection (which includes over 200 wedding poems, including another one in honor of 23-year old Moses Hayyim and Zipporah).
Related: Racy title page series at the Seforim Blog.
*To a more limited extent, this custom existed in other lands, including Germany.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Is Lakewood Yeshiva - BMG going to have a web site?
Domain Name: BMG.EDU
Registrant:
BETH MEDRASH GOVOHA
601 Private way
LAKEWOOD, NJ 08701
UNITED STATES
Administrative Contact:
AARON KOTLER
BETH MEDRASH GOVOHA
509 CAREY STREET
Lakewood, NJ 08701
UNITED STATES
(732)367-1060 x295
akotler@bmg.edu
Technical Contact:
Pessy Pollack
BETH MEDRASH GOVOHA
601 Private way
Lakewood, NJ 08701
UNITED STATES
(732)367-1060 x298
ppollack@bmg.edu
Name Servers:
NS1.SPEAKEASY.NET
NS2.SPEAKEASY.NET
Domain record activated: 25-Jan-2001
Domain record last updated: 08-Jun-2006
Domain expires: 31-Jul-2008
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
The history of the supposed credo of Karaism
A cardinal principle of early Karaism (and perhaps a popular saying among Karaites still, although I am unsure of that) is the following, which is attributed to Anan ben David, possibly a seminal figure in the founding of Karaism, but certainly a seminal figure in Karaism in general.
His saying is as follows:
חפישו באורייתא שפיר ואל תשענו על דעתי
"Search diligently in the Torah and don't rely on my opinion."
This credo really sums up the Karaite attitude toward Scripture. Independence of interpretation being seen as a desirable thing, even as it informs practical halakhic practice.
Someone pointed out that the first half is in Aramaic, while the second half is in Hebrew. Thus it would seem plausible that the second half is actually a gloss on the first. Perhaps Anan did say "Search diligently in the Torah," but perhaps someone else said "and don't rely on my opinion."
Tuesday, February 12, 2008
'Facing the Truths of History' revisited, pt. II; on the Weinberg-Atlas correspondence
Here is a quote from the Chopping Wood blog:
"While Dr. Shapiro's thesis about the Seridei Eish might certainly be true, the letters that he published were truly private. Rabbi Weinberg never published them, but instead sent them to a friend in confidence. After all, aren't private letters supposed to be confidential. In fact, Dr. Atlas saved his letters but never disseminated them publicly, and it was only his widow - who really had no appreciation for the implications of the publication of those letters -- who gave final permission for him to use them.
"To me, this raises the complicated issue of rabbinic privacy. Of course the Seridei Eish was a gadol, and his halachic works and other public writings have defined him for posterity. But does that public persona then make his entire life "public property"? Doesn't he also deserve to have a private life?" (emphasis mine)
The answer to that question must be "yes," however there is a common and widespread tradition in both Torah and Western scholarship of collecting and publishing the correspondence of notable people, particularly of the non-mundane variety (sometimes shopping lists are published, but you've got to be a George Washington for that, not a John Paul Jones). While this doesn't mean that there is therefore no such thing as the private life of the notable person, it does mean that the notable person does not write letters under the mistaken impression that they will never see the light of day.1 It is unlikely that R. Weinberg expected Prof. Atlas to destroy the letters he sent him, or that he could have had the expectation that no one would ever publish them.
Finally, there is the question of the judgment that the correspondence between a respected Orthodox rabbi and a Talmudic scholar in a Reform theological school2 would be embarrassing to the respected Orthodox rabbi. One could make a case that respected Orthodox rabbis who carry intimate correspondence with a Talmudic scholar in a Reform theological school are simply not like other Orthodox rabbis in the first place, and assuming the correspondence to be embarrassing is merely projection onto the respected Orthodox rabbi on the one hand, or perhaps the embarrassment is to elements within Orthodoxy that respect the rabbi on the other.
Indeed, in one of Prof. Atlas's published studies on the Talmud3 there is a letter from R. Weinberg printed, which highly praises these studies and wistfully observes that he wished that the traditionalist Torah students would read these studies and learn how to express themselves clearly, precisely and scientifically in Hebrew. Was this letter a secret and was Prof. Atlas wrong to have printed it?
R. Spolter (the Chopping Wood blogger) continues that he got when he challenged Shapiro on the issue of privacy, the latter agreed that he wouldn't be the one to reveal that a respected rabbi had an illegitimate child, provided that the rabbi had acted correctly as a father to that child. On the other hand, if the rabbi had not then he would publicize that fact. This then shows that even Marc Shapiro agrees that gedolim are entitled to a degree of privacy, even posthumously.
It is indeed interesting that Marc Shapiro personally feels that having an illegitimate child is not per se a diminution of the gadlus of a rabbi, but it is no chiddush that a responsible historian must distinguish between gossip and something of importance, nor is it a chiddush that sometimes what is or isn't gossip is basically a matter of opinion. These are problems, to be sure, but nothing ever leaves everyone happy.
Hat tip.
1 I would agree that a distinction might be made between letters from the notable person's youth--before they were notable--and afterward. People cannot predict their future, but the Weinberg-Atlas correspondence which was published in TUMJ begins in 1946.
2 Also notable is that R. Weinberg published a paper jointly with Paul Kahle in the Jewish studies annual of this very Reform theological school (see here if you want to read that paper). Perhaps the reader wishes to make a distinction between the relatively private life of R. Weinberg after WWII, and before when he was Rector of the Berlin Rabbinerseminar? While the Weinberg-Atlas letters were indeed from after the war, the HUCA article is from 1935.
3 I don't remember the name or much about it. I found it lying unloved on a shul's bookshelf, and only got to look at it for about twenty minutes.
Thursday, February 07, 2008
...and 'like an olive' used to be 'like an olive,' too...
"In today’s age we are extremely punctilious when it comes to various zemanim (assigned times). Take Shabbat, for example—we begin and end at a precise minute, and one that varies from week to week. I always wondered, however, exactly how in an era before clocks and watches were household items did people know when to light Shabbat candles. I assume most people did not own a sundial and you can’t always rely on the skies. So how did they know it was 4:53 pm and time to light the candles? Or that the eighteen minutes were up and you had to park your horse and walk home?Read the entire post.
"A few years ago I discovered the answer of how they told the difference between 4:53 and 5:07.
"Answer: they couldn’t tell the difference.
Thursday, January 31, 2008
Olomeinu
A friend* sent me a cartoon from a recent issue.**

(click to enlarge, or download it as a PDF; direct link)
My friend asked what my thoughts were. I remarked that it reminded me of a Chick tract (for a classic Chick tract, click here : Where's Rabbi Waxman?). I then said that I wondered if this sort of cartoon is something new for Olomeinu, or perhaps these sorts of polemical messages basically flew over my head as a child** (related).
Agreeing that the latter is a possibility, my friend shared the thoughts which had occurred. Since there was little I disagree with, here are my friend's thoughts:
- asking a question = chutzpadik
- asking questions leads to going off the derech
- going to college is equated with becoming irreligious
- three college professors would be travelling together in one car to go to a lecture, as though they were bachurim going to a chasunah
- the antiquated depiction of the professors
- the phone call later admitting that the Gemara was right, and in fact, all of Torah was right
All in all, this little gem is not half as interesting as the pearl unearthed by Blog in Dm.
All in all, I'm sure there will be an article devoted to these rare pieces of early 21st century Judaic ephemera in the American Jewish Historical Society journal. Perhaps I'll even rate a footnote.
*Who will be named, either by first or both names, or initials, if s/ he wishes.
** I honestly don't remember message of this sort, but I suspect that this isn't a new cartoon, but a reprint. Some things about it smells 1970s and not 2000s.
Let's play tag
Here's what I am assigned to do:
Although I am not supposed to cheat, I will cheat...a little. I'm going to have two entries. The first is, literally, the closest book I picked up. The second is also a book, it's also the first I opened in a blind search--but I have it in PDF.Pick up the nearest book of 123 pages or more. (No cheating!)
Find Page 123.
Find the first 5 sentences.
Post the next 3 sentences.
Tag 5 people.
1. The physical book:
This book [ie,Tychsen's Tentamen de Variis Codicum Hebraeorum... 1772] sought to undermine Kennicott's project by questioning the criteria by which biblical manuscripts were chosen and evaluated, as well as the quality of the manuscripts themselves. Tychsen was roundly criticized by a number of scholars, which in turn prompted him to publish a defense in 1774. Mendelssohn seemed to be keenly aware of the controversy over Tychsen's work and the climate that bred such a reaction, and he made it clear where his empathy lay.
Edward Breuer, The Limits of Enlightenment: Jews, Germany and the Eighteenth-Century Study of Scripture, pg. 123.
2. The e-book:
Which usage, by the by, I ob-
serve, renders the Hebrew language the
most perfectly consistent with itself (in the
eye of unprejudiced reason) of any lan-
guage on earth. I must now illustrate
the truth of all this, lest it be thought I in-
dulge myself in the luxuriance of im-
agination.
"It appears to have been Adam's man-
"ner in naming of things, to consider
"some particular observed of them, and
"from that to name them: thus knowing
"Eve to have been taken out of him,
"himself being called Aïsh (איש, Gen. ii. 23.)
"Man, he called her Ashah,
" which we render woman.
Norman Sievwright, The Hebrew Text Considered; Being Observations on the Novelty and Self-Inconsistency of the Masoretic Schem of Pointing the Sacred Hebrew Scriptures, 1764. pg. 124.
Other than changing the long S to our standard lowercase s (eg, I observe, rather than I obferve) I preserved the formatting of this book exactly, since it captures some of the...charm? history? to see such antiquated printing conventions as, for example, the means of quotation. Why is my quote from pg. 124? Because Sievwright was so wordy and Germanic, that the 6th, 7th and 8th sentence from the beginning of pg. 123 is on pg. 124!
I tag Ari, Ishim, Dave, Gil, and Menachem.
Tuesday, January 29, 2008
"Even a Galician melammed"--; an apologetic for the Hebrew textus receptus by R. Chaim Heller
For more on R. Heller, see.
Rabbi Prof. David Weiss-Halivni wins Israel Prize 2008
Halivni has written seven volumes of critical research on the Talmud. He has taught at Columbia University in New York for many years and made aliya to Jerusalem in 2005. Halivni currently also teaches at both Bar-Ilan University and The Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Halivni was born in the Ukraine in 1927. He received smicha at the age of 15 and was the sole survivor of the Holocaust from his family.
According to the judges, "Prof. David Halivni is one of the premier researchers into the Talmud of our generation. He merges the old with the new pioneering new methods of research," the judges, Profs. Daniel Sperber, Shlomo Naeh, and Aharon Kirschenbaum said.
link
מזל טוב!
Download and read the very interesting New York Times Magazine profile "A Life in the Talmud," by Israel Shenker, 9.11.77: here.
Monday, January 28, 2008
Polyglot
The last (but most accurate) of these great Bibles, Walton's London Polyglot of 1657 (actually titled Biblia Sacra Polyglotta) included the following versions:
1) Hebrew (with Latin translation), 2) the Latin Vulgate, 3) the Greek Septuagint (with Latin translation), 4) the Syriac Peshitta (with Latin translation), 5) Targum Onqelos (with Latin translation), 5) Samaritan Hebrew, 6) Samaritan Targum (with Latin translation), 7) Arabic (with Latin translation). Parts of the Bible have Ethiopic and Persian versions.
Here's the first two pages of Genesis (actual size is 18" high):

(click to enlarge, or buy one yourself (if $15,000 is doable--brand new, they sold for £9)

Brian Walton
Thursday, January 24, 2008
How an early Polish maskil learned how to read European languages
Here's an interesting excerpt from Solomon Maimon's (1754-1800) autobiography1:
I possessed some disconnected knowledge in history, astronomy, and other mathematical sciences. I burned with desire to acquire more knowledge, but how was this to be accomplished in the want of guidance, of scientific books, and of all other means for the purpose ? I was obliged therefore to content myself with making use of any help that I could by chance obtain, without plan or method.
In order to gratify my desire of scientific knowledge, there were no means available but that of learning foreign languages. But how was I to begin ? To learn Polish or Latin with a Catholic teacher was for me impossible, on the one hand because the prejudices of my own people prohibited to me all languages but Hebrew, and all sciences but the Talmud and the vast array of its commentators, on the other hand because the prejudices of Catholics would not allow them to give instruction in those matters to a Jew. Moreover I was in very low temporal circumstances. I was obliged to support a whole family by teaching, by correcting proofs of the Holy Scriptures, and by other work of a similar kind. For a long time therefore I had to sigh in vain for the satisfaction of my natural inclination.
At last a fortunate accident came to my help. I observed in some stout Hebrew volumes, that they contained several alphabets, and that the number of their sheets was indicated not merely by Hebrew letters, but that for this purpose the characters of a second and a third alphabet had also been employed, these being commonly Latin and German letters. Now, I had not the slightest idea of printing. I generally imagined that books were printed like linen, and that each page was an impression from a separate form. I presumed however that the characters, which stood in similar places, must represent one and the same letter, and as I had already heard something of the order of the alphabet in these languages, I supposed that, for example, a, standing in the same place as aleph, must likewise be an aleph in sound. In this way I gradually learnt the Latin and German characters.
By a kind of deciphering I began to combine various German letters into words ; but as the characters used along with the Hebrew letters might be something quite different from these, I remained always doubtful whether the whole of my labour in this operation would not be in vain, till fortunately some leaves of an old German book fell into my hand. I began to read. How great were my joy and surprise, when I saw from the connection, that the words completely corresponded with those which I had learned. 'Tis true, in my Jewish language many of the words were unintelligible ; but from the connection I was still able, with the omission of these words, to comprehend the whole pretty well.
1 "Solomon Maimon: an Autobiography: Tr. from the German with Additions and Notes," translated by John Clark Murray, 1888, pp.89-91.
If you don't have time or interest in reading the entire autobiography, you can read what is essentially an 18-page synopsis (with interesting commentary) here, in an essay from 1895.
Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Mining the wealth in the digitization projects
1) Moses Israel Landau's edition of the Aruch (1819-1835): I, II, III, IV
2) Joseph Derenbourg's edition of Saadiah Gaon's Tafsir (1893).
3) Moise Schwab's Talmud Yerushalmi Berakhoth, English translation of the French (1886).
4) Abraham Berliner's edition of Rashi (1905).
5) Leone da Modena's autobiographical Ḥaye Yehudah.
6) Yasha"r Reggio's edition of the aforementioned Leone da Modena's Behinat ha-qabbalah, with Qol Sakhal and Sha'agat Aryeh.
7) Nachman Krochmal's More nevukhe ha-zeman.
8) Hayyim Yoseph David Azulay's Shem ha-gedolim he-ḥadash.
9) Samuel David Luzzatto's Isaiah with Italian translation and comentary, 1867.
10) Yom Tov Zunz's Namen der Juden (see, I've already violated my Hebrew/ English quasi-rule).
11) Adolph Jellinek's edition of the Haqdamah to Minchat Shai
12) Ḥayyim Heller's Al Targum ha-Yerushalmi la-Torah (1921).
13) Simcha Pinsker's Likute Kadmoniyot.
===========
Much more to come, I think.
Also, please note that the time is short for me right now. I will edit this post with more information about the names and works in this post.
Monday, January 21, 2008
Wolf Heidenheim as antiquarian, in a Feldheim book about Chasam Sofer

This book seems to have originally been published in 1933 as Licht aus dem Western, seemingly by the original Agudath Israel (Agudas Jisroel-Jungendgruppe) and the present work is the translation into English from 1969, by Joseph Leftwich.
In any event, this excerpt concerns R. Nathan Adler (this one, not this one) and Wolf Heidenheim.



Bony or not, here is an image of Heidenheim (from here):

* In this "new, revised edition," 'Selig' is spelled 'Zelig.'
Thursday, January 17, 2008
How something said by a person who died 80 years ago can be mistaken for a מאמר חז"ל
In yesterday's Seforim post by Marc Shapiro writes the following:
[Here is an] "announcement by Agudas ha-Rabbonim, which appeared in Ha-Pardes, November 1975.

"Yet the beautiful thought which the learned rabbis assume was stated by Hazal was actually stated by Ahad ha-Am, and is perhaps his most famous saying.[34] However, for one whose only Jewish knowledge comes from the yeshiva, this information would be unknown, and it is easy to see how such a statement (“more than the Jews have kept the Sabbath the Sabbath has kept the Jews”) could “infiltrate” this closed world and become just another ma’amar hazal."
While this is not the same thing as a statement by the Agudas Ha-rabbonim calling a ma'amar Ahad Ha'am a ma'amar Hazal, I recall a few years ago a rabbi quoted this aphorism (without attribution to Hazal) in the Country Yossi Family Magazine. A reader sent a letter saying what the source was and that therefore the statement was wrong. The rabbi responded that whoever said it, it's true!
Wednesday, January 16, 2008
On Hebrew paleography
a. The study of ancient writing and inscriptions; the science or art of deciphering and interpreting historical manuscripts and writing systems.
Basic Rules of Hebrew Palaeography
8. The stylistic changes are caused by a variety of factors, of which the following are most important: time and place, the writing materials and implements, the speed of writing, and the influence of imitation of other scripts.
a. Time. A script, like a language, changes in the course of time, even when a tradition is strictly followed. A minimal change may develop a dynamic of its own and gather momentum in a certain direction, thus influencing the evolution of the script. Sometimes a change in the letterforms is temporary, leaving no trace in the script's subsequent development, as in the case of the idiosyncrasy of a certain scribe. Changes that become systematic are, as we said, stylistic changes. One of the major changes in a script - one which develops slowly - is the change in the relative size of the letters of the alphabet. Thus, for example, there is a difference in the relative size of the letter-signs in the script of the early scroll fragments from Qumran and the script used in manuscripts two centuries later (quite apart from other formal changes in the script). Rapid changes in the letter-forms are generally due to fluent writing with ink. Scripts of different degrees of cursiveness may sometimes be used for different purposes, such as writing official documents as against private letters. Script-styles constantly change and the situation is never static.
b. The nature of writing materials and writing implements. Letters of one and the same script-style will have different appearances when written with different instruments on different surfaces. There is a difference between writing in ink on a soft surface and inscribing letters on a hard material. The writing implement, whether a brush, or a reed-pen, a quill, a chisel, etc., and the way the implement is cut and held, also influence the form of the letters. A careful examination of their inner structure will reveal the common features of the letter-forms. On the other hand, the use of different implements and materials can result in formal changes in the script which can become stylistic. Thus, for example, it is difficult to draw horizontal strokes from right to left or vertical strokes in an upward direction with a flat writing implement held in the right hand, while such strokes are easily made with a sharp or round writing implement. A flat pen, unlike a sharp or round pen, can be used for writing letters with thick and thin strokes and ornaments, which may become stylistic features of that particular script.
c. The speed of writing. Writing on soft surfaces, unlike writing on a hard material, usually encourages flowing movements which may cause rapid changes in the form of the letters. Already in ancient times, a reed-pen or brush was used for writing in ink. As a result of this fluent writing, the forms of the letter-strokes as well as their meeting points and the forms of their joints underwent fundamental changes. The lapidary script usually continues to exist together with the cursive hands and there was a mutual influence on their letter-forms; cursive found their way into the lapidary script and vice versa. This process gave rise to a large variety of letter-forms of different degrees of cursiveness, and cursive and semi-cursive script-styles emerged which were sometimes used concurrently for different purposes.
d. The geographical factor and the influence of imitation of other scripts. The Jewish script, and later the Hebrew script, evolved many styles due to contact with foreign scripts. Already before the dispersion of the Jews throughout the world, the Jewish script came into contact with the Greek and Latin scripts as well as the Nabatean script. In later times many new script-styles evolved among the Jewish communities in the different countries, with the influence of the foreign scripts as well as the use of different writing implements and materials. The changes in the letter-forms were sometimes due to deliberate imitation and they sometimes occurred unintentionally, mainly because the continual use of foreign scripts together with the Hebrew script occasionally caused changes in the hand-movement of bilingual scribes. Thus the Hebrew scripts in the Islamic countries show affinities with the Arabic script while the Hebrew scripts in Christian Europe show affinities with the Latin script-styles used in the different countries.
The more strict the scribal tradition was, the less recognizable were the changes. Thus, for instance, in the calligraphic square Hebrew script which was used for the writing of sacred texts from the 9th century onwards, minimal changes occurred in the course of times, while the cursive and semi-cursive script-styles, which evolved at about the same time, show considerable changes in the form of the letter-signs. However, even the calligraphic square scripts used for sacred purposes underwent stylistic changes. Thus the number of ornamental additions increased as well as the variety of letter-f0rms of the joints between the letter strokes.
Ada Yardeni, The Book of Hebrew Script: History, Palaeography, Script Styles, Calligraphy & Design, 2002, pp. 139-143.
Tuesday, January 15, 2008
A little-known zeikher vs zekher issue; Franz Delitzsch, Wolf Heidenheim and the Mishnah Berurah.
I assumed I had done a post about this, but searches revealed that I didn't, and I was shocked. There is little to add to a topic that is of great interest to Judeo-nitpickers like us (discussed on the mail lists here, here and here (sort of). It's been discussed on blogs too, see here. There is also a very good lecture by Dr. Sid Leiman here--if the audo is still active--' Major Implications of Pronounciation Controversies').
This topic presumably fascinates those who it fascinates because it would seem quite amazing that a verse which the Talmud itself discusses as being prone to misunderstanding based upon an erroneous pronunciation (see here) would then become subject to confusion as to proper pronunciation (although it is important to recognize that there is no practical difference in meaning between זֵכֶר and זֶכֶר). The second factor might be that this confusion led to such a far-reaching but very late change in practice.
So there is no need to add more, but actually, before I go on I will add one thing. Here in America many Orthodox Jews have become accustomed to the reading of this verse twice, to accommodate both possible readings (something which seems to be first recommended by the Mishneh Berurah (685:18)1 apparently based on the doubt about what the Gaon of Vilna read).
In the 5768 issue of Yerushaseinu there was an exchange between Robert Aumann and editor David Hirshaut about transliterating the Central European Ashkenazic pronunciation in English. The following is an excerpt by Aumann (thanks to Menachem):

Wow!
In any event, this is obviously not the little-known zeikher vs zekher issue of the title. What is little-known is that the exact same doubt exists for Proverbs 7:10; זֵכֶר צַדִּיק לִבְרָכָה.
The great Hebraist Franz Delitzsch2 wrote the following in his commentary on Proverbs:

Apparently the manuscripts showed five and six points for this verse as well. It seems that a similar confusion exists in Ashrei (see here).
Delitzsch instructs the reader to "vid. Heidenheim in his ed. of the Pentateuch, Meor Enajim, under Ex. xvii. 14." So I thought it prudent to aid the reader to have a vid. for oneself; the masoretic commentary 'Eyn Ha-qore of Wolf Heidenheim in his edition of the Torah, the חומש מאור עינים (see here):



If anyone has the time, feel free to track down images of Proverbs 7:10 as found in various editions available online.
1 בנגינתם ובטעמם - דע דיש אומרים שצריך לקרות זכר עמלק בציר"י ויש אומרים שצריך לקרות זכר עמלק בסגו"ל וע"כ מהנכון שהקורא יקרא שניהם לצאת י"ש
2 Delitzsch was relatively unusual as far as Christian Hebraists of the 19th century went in that he was very well read in contemporary and recent Jewish Hebrew literature and commentaries. He was a big advocate of the excellence of the commentaries of Shadal and Malbim (and was personally in correspondence with the former). Not only was he familiar with all the work of Wolf Heidenheim, but also the Gaon of Vilna, whom he cited. With this description, it shouldn't be a surprise that he was a welcome font of philo-semitism in the 19th century world of German Bible scholarship.
Monday, January 14, 2008
Hebrew origin for Latin and Greek words in R. Azariah dei Rossi's Me'or Enayim.

This is a very interesting excerpt from chapter 57 of R. Azariah dei Rossi's controversial but classic Me'or Enayim.
Chapter 57 discusses the antiquity of the Hebrew language, according to the convention of the time, with copious proofs and analysis of the evidence available to the author. In this excerpt, etymologies for Greek and Latin words are derived from Hebrew (I decided to break the passage into paragraphs for ease of reading):
"Also, among the works of scholarship by Rabbi David Provençale1, that flag-bearer of Torah from Mantua (lit. Min-tova; of goodness in Hebrew), is Dor Ha-felagah, in which more than 2000 Hebrew words that became incorporated into the Latin, Greek and Italian languages are given.
"An example in Latin is uxor (wife) from ezer ke-negdo (helpmeet), axillae (armpit) from atzilei yadai (my arm joints).
"The Greek and Latin pellex (concubine) comes from Hebrew pilegesh. Ospedale (hospital) comes from osef dalim (gathering of the indigent).
"Calliope, the first of the nine Muses, the Muse of music, is from qol yafeh (beautiful voice), according to the compiler of the Latin dictionary.2 He also says that the word kalendae comes from qol, as I wrote earlier.
"Accademia is from the words beit eqed ro'im (shearing house of shepherds), which Targum Jonathan translates as "a meeting house of shepherds"--and from adam (man), thus meaning a gathering of people.
"I gave this explanation regarding an chevras chachomim (academy) recently founded here in Ferrara. The first lecturer described this institution as an "academy," and someone didn't like that description, since it would be strange for a Jewish society to bear a Greek name. And then I told him that the word might have been derived from Hebrew, and he was satisfied and appeased. "
1 Although this work is not extant, Steinschneider refers to it here.
2 In Joanna Weinberg's wonderful annotated translation of Me'or Enayim, she identifies this citation as Ambrogio Calepino, Dictionarium, s.v. Calliope.
Friday, January 11, 2008
Halakhic nightmare scenario
The twins were separated at birth and not told they had any siblings. They were adopted by different families, and - amazingly - as adults they met, fell in love and married.
The High Court ruled the marriage had never been valid and annulled it.
Further details of the case, and the identity of the twins, have been kept secret to protect them.
Professor Lord Alton, who uncovered the case, said: "The right for children to know the identity of their biological parents is a human right.
"There will be more cases like this if children are not given access to the truth."
Thursday, January 10, 2008
Soncino Talmud statistics
Vilna Gaon 118
Rashi 3361
Jastrow 686
Danby 8
C.D. Ginsburg 1
Louis Ginzberg 24
Bah 383
Akiba Eger 2
Alexander Kohut 10
Zacharias Frankel 11
Abraham Geiger 6
Lazarus Goldschmidt 39
David Zvi Hoffmann 11
Chasam Sofer 2
Heinrich Graetz 63
I. Halevy 38
Isaak Hirsch Weiss 105
Aruch 180+
Wilhelm Gesenius 3
Maharsha 164
Abraham Firkowitz 1
Leopold Zunz 4
Tos. Yom Tov 19
Obadiah Bertinoro 19
Nachman Krochmal 5
Maharatz Chajes 7
Jacob Zebi Meklenburg 4
Malbim 13
Hermann Strack 8
Wilhelm Bacher 53
Barukh Ha-levi Epstein (Torah Temimah) 2
Saul Lieberman 1
Kaufmann Kohler 4
Jacob Emden 18
Samuel Krauss 161
Solomon Zeitlin 9
Adolf Buchler 58
Ludwig Blau 23
Shi"r Rapoport (spelled Rappaport) 9
Maharshal (under Rashal) 98
Nathan Nota Rabbinowitz (also cz) 8, plus Dikduke Sofrim 4 and Munich MS 10
Robert Travers Herford 39
James Montgomery 4
Alexander Marx 1
Max L. Margolis 1
Adolf Jellinek 2
Judah David Eisenstein 2
(to be updated)
R. Hirschenson's responsum on Bible criticism; an Orthodox road not traveled.
From chapter 7 of We Have Reason To Believe (1957):
"One of the most original thinkers among the Rabbis of the older school, Rabbi Hayyim Hirschenson, wrote some years ago a fascinating Responsum on the Jewish attitude to Bible Criticism. Hirschenson, who was asked if Bible Criticism may be taught at the Hebrew University, endeavoured to apply Halachic method to the problem. The Halachah knows of three categories with regard to liability—these are, hayyabh, 'obligation', i.e. the incurment of a penalty; patur 'exemption' but assur 'forbidden', i.e. though there is no penalty for the offence there is prohibition; and patur and muttar, 'exempt and permitted', i.e. not only is there no penalty but there is no prohibition. With regard to Sabbath law, for instance, work prohibited in the Bible involves the full penalty of Sabbath desecration; work forbidden by rabbinic law is prohibited but there is no penalty attached to the prohibition; and there are certain forms of work involving no prohibition whatsoever. Hirschenson suggests (Maiki Ba-Kodesh, Vol. I and II, St. Louis, 1919-1921) that the main objection in the Talmudic sources to the rejection of the doctrine of 'Torah from Heaven' is that such a rejection impugns the honesty of Moses by suggesting that he wrote something he had not received from God. The hayyabh offence in this field, for which the penalty of exclusion from the World to Come is incurred, is the denigration of Moses' character in maintaining that he willfully forged the Biblical documents. On the other hand, the study of textual criticism is both patur and muttar, for, as we have seen, such criticism was at times resorted to in the Talmudic age. Modern Bible Criticism does not suggest that Moses forged the documents but that they are not the work of Moses at all. This, because it is in opposition to the established traditions of our people, is assur 'forbidden', but not hayyabh. Hence, Hirschenson concludes it would not be necessary for the orthodox Jew to boycott the Hebrew University because some of its Professors espouse the cause of Higher Criticism."
To expand on these words, the responsum begins by noting that as in all areas of Jewish law, there are subtle distinctions between different acts, as in hilkhos shabbos. For example, there are those things for which a person is hayav. There is patur aval assur. There is patur and mutar. He proceeds to explain how these distinctions apply to Bible criticism.
In the first case, one is hayav (by this he means hayav kares) if they say that Moshe wrote something in the Torah which he did not receive from God. (Parenthetically, this is either naivety, since Bible criticism does not generally accept that Moshe wrote anything at all or it is merely an attempt to frame the issue in traditional parlance, since the Talmud contemplates the heresy of denying that Moshe wrote the Torah by God's instruction, but not that he wrote it himself.)
In the category of patur aval assur is higher Bible criticism, that is he says that this or that part of the Torah was taken from another place, wasn't written by Moshe, etc. While this is a very bad thing, and is prohibited he is not hayav kares, nor he has not forfeited his heleq in olam habah. But it's a very bad thing. Similarly, with lower Bible criticism, a textual critic who investigates the history of the text of the Torah who plans to establish a text which is different from the present one (contra R. Jacobs who does not note this distinction, but only the one below).
In the third, patur and mutar, he places a textual critic who has no plan to change anything, but he uses critical tools for better understanding the text, or even to study Higher Criticism for the sake of knowledge, which is a good thing since it enables one to answer the epiqoros. This is no different from the Rambam's study of Greek philosophy, which contained good things and also many things that contradict religion and need to be rejected. This would be forbidden to teach children, but grown men who are university students are capable of making distinctions and can handle this material.
Finally, a fourth category, which is both a mitzvah and obligation: to become learned in massorah and dikduk, as this is an exalted practice of our forbearers and it strengthens the Torah.
For more on R. Hirschensohn (who was an associate of Ben Yehuda), see.
This teshuva and a lot more fascinating discussion can be found toward the end of מלכי בקדש חלק ב.
Thanks to Dan for suggesting this post. (link)
The penalty meted out by the British Army to two Redcoats for desecrating Siphrei Torah during the American Revolution
During the war of the revolution, two british soldiers broke into the Synagogue in Mill Street, and Stole the remonim; destroyed two of the Seapharim,* and threw them into the sink; the Soldiers were apprehended and Severely flogged, one of them died from the effects.
* One of the above Sepharim was on Ivory rollers and belonged to the late Mr. Uriah Hendricks, & the other to the Congregation.
From "Naphtali Phillips, pg. 216, PAJHS Journal 21 (1913).
In this book from 1955 there is a photo of one of the scrolls, which was still kept in the ארון הקודש, and perhaps still is today. Unfortunately I don't have this photo at my disposal, but the Torah looked wrinkled (like it had been wet) with two or three holes with blackened edges.
Tuesday, January 08, 2008
Este grande misvah de פדיון שבויים


Edit: A. posted a translation of this letter: link.
Sunday, January 06, 2008
A Hebrew grammar with English and 'German' translation (in Hebrew letters) from 1904
This book, תורת שפת עבר: ללמד בני ישראל דרכי לשון הקודש ומשפטיה, published in New York in 1904, was written by Simon Hertz, the father of Rabbi Joseph H. Hertz (1872-1846). He lived from 1846 to 1913 (see) having emigrated to the United States from Slovakia in 1884 (see). According to Meirovich's book on the Hertz Pentateuch, he was a musmach of R. Esriel Hildesheimer in Eisenstadt (where the latter resided prior to
The book is aimed at children, and so illustrates each lesson with a little poem (in English and
Letters of the "Holy Tongue"
Are Twenty-Two by name;
Every Hebrew while yet young,
Should strive to know the same.
It contains other ditties like
Paragogic of no benefit
Unless a better sound to obtain,
Why in the Scriptures they did admit,
These אהוי"ן 'tis hard to explain.
and this classic:
שוא as a vowel you must not count,
No power of vowels does it possess;
Its existence is paramount,
To a display of vowel-lessness.
There are a few interesting features of this Hebrew grammar (in English with Yiddish on facing pages). For one thing, although the author calls the Yiddish language 'Jewish-German' in English, he calls it אשכנז in Hebrew. For another, in Solomon Schechter's הסכמה (see below) rather than Yiddish or Jewish-German, it is called 'German.'* Make of that what you will.
Also interesting is the list of patrons who donated $10, $5 and $3 towards publication of the book (funds total less than $300).


Thursday, January 03, 2008
A michtam* for Artscroll
It may soon be time to reflect on this blog and to revisit my "Who am I" page. But first, a short thought.
In the second volume of Hakirah there is a letter from Yaakov Elman, part of which reads as follows:
"I wish you all the luck in the world in cultivating intellectual curiosity in Flatbush and among frum people in general. Decades of experience have shown me how difficult a task that is. Good luck!"
On the other hand, a mere three years experience has shown me that much that could not be accomplished from within the ivory tower can be accomplished from without. Please don't think of this as any sort of condescension, veiled or otherwise, toward my readers and blogging chaveirim. On the contrary, many people who know a lot more about the things I'm interested in and have known them for a lot longer than me seem to read this blog and contribute to the comments. But not everyone in 'Blogistan' fit that description, and I'm happy to say that you can cultivate intellectual curiosity among frum people, to say nothing of the curiosity which is already there.
This funny poem by Jacqueline Osherow is from her Dead Men's Praise, a book of poems "address travels in Italy, the vanished Jewish world of the Ukraine, and insights into the nature of God that can be gleaned from the Hebrew psalms."

By the way, I'm always so critical of Artscroll, but the distant dove of silence sounds perfectly poetic to me, not that it seems to actually mean anything.
(Complete poem is on pp. 69-72.)
Another excerpt:
To my bubbe, I'd have written michtam
Upon michtam. Who decides when it's a michtam?
*מכתם

