I realize this is a midrash. But how do Midrashic literalists understand writing thirteen Torahs in one day? (Or even in ten years?) This is something that I've never seen addressed, neither the mechanics of writing thirteen sifrei Torah or what sort of metaphorical message lies in this midrash. Any thoughts?
Wednesday, August 31, 2005
Moshe's 13 Torahs
I realize this is a midrash. But how do Midrashic literalists understand writing thirteen Torahs in one day? (Or even in ten years?) This is something that I've never seen addressed, neither the mechanics of writing thirteen sifrei Torah or what sort of metaphorical message lies in this midrash. Any thoughts?
Time for a new Encyclopaedia Judaica
In 2003 Thomson Gale announced that it had acquired a "cultural treasure", the rights to publish the second edition of the Encyclopaedia Judaica.
The first edition was published by Keter Publishing House, a leading publisher in Israel. With the 2nd Edition, Gale will be working hand-in-glove with Keter to create an equally rich yet more robust version. Gale's revision - to be published under its Macmillan imprint - will be the first completely updated print edition in 30 years, said Allen Paschal, president of Gale. "Jewish studies have transformed significantly since the original edition. We are working with Keter to line up an editorial board of Israeli, U.S., and European Judaica scholars that reflects the state of Jewish studies today."Here is the entry on the late Nahum Sarna that will be in the new edition.
In addition to giving due attention to important Judaica subjects of recent decades, the Gale edition will introduce a key improvement: seamless integration of the base set, supplements, updates from the CD-ROM, and new content.
The Encyclopaedia Judaica is considered a cultural icon in Israel and throughout the world and is universally acclaimed as the definitive reference source on Jewish life, culture, religion and history. "The reverence for this book is apparent when watching political coverage on Israeli television where it's common to see the first edition of The Encyclopaedia Judaica located near officials' desks," Paschal said. "It's a symbol of learning and culture."
Marketplace conversations with librarians have indicated that a single, synthesized version of The Encyclopaedia Judaicawould be a valuable improvement over the current formats. Subject areas likely to be targeted in the new edition include events of the last 30 years; the State of Israel today; bibliographies; archaeological discoveries; new areas of scholarship; and the Holocaust studies. As great as the EJ is, it was published in 1972 so the prospect of a new one excites me inordinately.
As great as the EJ is, it was published in 1972 so the prospect of a new one excites me inordinately. The new edition has big shoes to fill. Here's wishing it won't be a lemon.
Tuesday, August 16, 2005
Karaites, tefillin, masorah and archaology
There also are different groups of karaism who can't seem to stand each other, but I am not really aware of the details here. The Karaite World Union seems to be Egyptian dominated though and [Karaites] of Crimean origin seem to make several of these claimsA split among the latter day Karaites? I didn't know about that, but could it be that the Egyptian Karaites have become "Rabbanized"? The Crimeans, more willing to follow archaeological findings, rejecting their "masorah"?
1) Tefilin should be worn, since archeologist findings prove that the "tefilin verses" in Torah are not a metaphor.
2) The KWU's conversion requirements don't meet the Tanach's requirements.
3) The structures of the KWU contradict the Tanach.
Conversely, we "rabbanites" seem may have split or are splitting into neo-Karaized and non-Karaized factions regarding our own texts and traditions.
Nishtaneh ha-trousers
Believing wholeheartdely that the old scholars are infallible, Ludwig Duret (16th century) tried to solve in a peculiar way a contradiction between Hippocrates and Galen. According to the former each lung consists of three lobes; the latter, however, maintained that it consists of two lobes. Duret explained that in the time of Hippocrates all human beings were stronger, no doubt because their organs were better developed.Zimmels H.J., The Signifigance of the Statement "We are not acquainted any more" as Echoed in Rabbinic Literature (New York: Shulsinger Brothers, 1962), pp.229 in Leo Jung Jubilee VolumeSimilarly, when Vesalius (1514-64) proved that Galen's description of hip-bones were wrong, the excuse offered for Galen's error was that man's shape had changed through wearing tight trousers.
Monday, August 15, 2005
Too many books, not enough minutes
Zaid convincingly estimates that since the invention of moveable type printing in the mid-15th century, something like 52 million titles have been published. The number is obviously huge, but how huge? Zaid goes on to put things into perspective. Were one to make reading their full time vocation, with reading an average of four books a week, fifty years into the project you'd have read about 10,000 books. That is, one out of every 50,000 books.
Let's try to pare down 52,000,000 to a manageable number. After all, most of them are junk anyway. Drop two million for fun, and let's assume that 90% of the remaining 50 million are complete and total trash. Of the 5 million remaining, let's assume that 90% are essentially repetitious; in the genre of great novels, for example, if you've read Huckleberry Finn then you don't really need to read Tom Sawyer. If you've read one Dostoevsky that's enough--enough Dostoevsky and enough great Russian literature.So that leaves us with 500,000 books that are not complete trash and that are not essentially restatements of other books. Let's assume that by eliminating those books that aren't available in, say, only English or Hebrew* and books that aren't really meant to be read (e.g., dictionaries) that we're left with 100,000 books that aren't total trash, that aren't info you can get in other books, that aren't technical and that aren't only available in English or Hebrew.
If in 50 years of reading full time you can read 10,000 max, if you become a masmid and read 16 hours a day then you can read 20,000. If you're granted long life, then in a hundred years you can read--just one time--40,000 or so of the 100,000 books that are worth reading. By satisfying almost impossible conditions you can read 40% of the worthwhile reading that is available to you, and read them only one time each. Of course that's just crazy talk. A much more realistic estimate is that a voracious reader will read two or three thousand books in their lifetime, and let's not pretend that a great deal of it won't be things that would have been better not to have read.
¡Ay, caramba!
Zaid's book is actually a celebration of books. He freely acknowledges that he isn't ever going to read all of the 10,000 books in his library and says that no one with great libraries is under a different illusion.
*Oh, and speaking of sefarim does anyone have any idea of a reliable estimate for how many Judaic works have been written? Realizing the borders on this are really hard to define, if I had to guess it wouldn't surprise me if a cool million separate Jewish titles have been written.
Elazar ha-Kalir's J'Accuse; Ey koh
Friday, August 12, 2005
Sof horaa and the redaction the Talmud
Thursday, August 11, 2005
Fresh lemon juice on fresh wounds
DovBear posted about what one might learn from the impending Gaza event. He says that
the Gaza withdrawl is an act of Teshuva. The nation and the people are repenting for abiding 30 years of Jim Crow conditions in YeshaNow, it is obvious if you read the entire post that DovBear meant no malice and that he worded it very carefully. After citing Rashi on tzaraas, he says it is his "abiding hope that a "treasure of gold" waits for the nation and the people who complete this process."
And yet, the only substantial differences between this post on the eve of the impending disaster for the people so affected and Toby Katz's posts on the Holocaust is, arguably, that Toby didn't bend over backwards to appear as sensitive as she could have, although I don't think she was being malicious either. But there is another difference in that the Holocaust ended 60 years ago. Is it a closed wound? Certainly not. But some scar tissue has built up there. The Holocaust 'takes' far worse than Toby Katz' Holocaust theology.
The wounds of Monday's Gaza disaster (if one can define the eviction of 8000 people as a disaster, which I think one can) are so fresh that the cut's haven't even started bleeding yet (metaphorical blood, I hope). No matter which way I read DovBear's post I see lemon juice being poured into wounds. Put aside the Jim Crow issue--I think he meant well despite my strong disagreement, and that's what distresses me about it so much. Its so insensitive that it's mean.
Koffehouse kabbalah
This very interesting post by Chakira called to my attention an article called 'Coffee, coffeehouses, and the nocturnal rituals of early modern Jewry' by Elliott S. Horowitz (AJS Review 14,1 (1989) 17-46.) The premise: Kabbalistic midnight rituals, such as tikkun chatzos or tikkun leil shavuos came to be in each place that it did with the introduction of coffee. The use of coffee as a stimulant might have encouraged the mystics of Tzefat to focus on all-night and late-night rituals because they couldn't sleep anyway. Horowitz demonstrates that such midnight rituals happened where and when coffee became available; in Tzefat in the mid-16th century. In Italy, in the early 17th century, and in Germany in the 18th century.
summary of Friedman's article
What's the point? Nothing. It takes nothing away from tikkunei chatzos or leil shavuos. But it is an interesting correlation.
However I have a two-part question. His answer suffices for today what will be the answer in a hundred years from now if Orthodoxy is still vibrant, as it hopefully will be? You can't really give the rebound-from-the-brink answer forever.
Secondly, what would he have said is the compelling answer 60 years ago when it looked like it was all over?
In other words, I think his wonderful post is very time-bound. So what is the timeless answer?
Wednesday, August 10, 2005
Torah and popular culture: Milton isn't just an 80-year old Jewish guy
not everyone sees the same insights in the same place. Some people (like me) gain very little from Shakespeare because of a pitiable lack of background and interest. Sure, if Rabbi Carmy or R. Aharon Lichtenstein spell out a valuable tidbit from Milton then I will grasp it. But, sadly, I lack the interest in searching for such insights myself.....It is my belief that Torah Im Derekh Eretz (which Dr. Lamm classifies as a form of Torah U-Mada) includes contemporary popular culture. The only reason to exclude it is old-fogeyism and cultural bias. Is there bad pop culture? Yes. Is there bad 19th century literature? Yes. Are there aspects of pop culture that are assur? Same thing goes for 19th century culture. The bold TIDE-nik will find the gems and utilize them for positive purposes.
Figure out how to concentrate in tefillah and don't despair
Many years ago I bought some seforuim on various tefilos are learnt them. However I quickly discovered that given the time to for instance say ashrei, it’s not realistic to be mechavain anything.....The problem with tefilah - is that the point is to communicate and think NOT mumble through an extraordinary number of words per minute and space out. Yet we do. And you see from how the halacha is set up - we are forced to. And despite asking numerous talmidei chachomim and looking around in various acharonim I have never seen any kind of explanation. It’s maddening.I say that the problem is that people think halakha is like chemistry. H20 = water and all that.
The truth is that if it will aid your tefillah to spend the 10 minutes of pesukei de-zimrah saying only ashrei, then by all means do so. Same goes for all teffilos that are in the siddur. There are certain ones that have priority, and even in the certain ones (such as the amidah) there are certain berachos with priority.
Unfortunately "they" won't tell the rabbim that one really doesn't have to daven every single word if it will damage his tefillah.
Use your head, man. It's like when they tell you that if you say a single word of lashon hara as defined by the Chafetz Chaim then every good thing you did in your entire life promptly disappears. Take it for what it is, a polemical point that lashon hara is a sin.
This is definitely not an argument against being medakdek in halakha or striving for that. But it is an observable fact that it is impossible for a human being to excel in every fine point of every law as codified in the texts, or at least not for an average human being (e.g., most people). What if you don't get out of bed like a lion (first siman Shulhan Arukh)? Does that mean that you "don't follow the Shulhan Arukh" and thus aren't frum? Nonsense. The point of halakha isn't to make people drown, and if someone is drowning in it then they have to assess how they will stay afloat. If in the case of tefillah it is a choice between having kavvana for a couple of things or having no kavvanah at all and frantically mumbling it all out the choice is clear.
Tuesday, August 09, 2005
E N I L N I A M E H T N O

E N I L N I A M E H T N O
You do realize, don't you, that the Ketav ‘Ivri in your title says ‘onat hhaham, ein lina don't you? I assume that hhaham is a scribal error for original hhakham, and therefore the inscription reads "in the season of a sage, there is no rest". deep."In the season of a sage, there is no rest. I like it!
They hear but do not understand, they have eyes but do not see
I'm curious how people can learn something without understanding it and apparently thinking that they do understand. They must think they understand, right? How else could they learn it? What does someone who knows nothing of math or science think he's doing when he learns Gemara that deals with these subjects? How can he not be aware that he doesn't know what's going on??I was immediately reminded not to underestimate the power of cognitive dissonance. How many people "have heard the word "firmament" but have never looked up what it means?", Mis-nagid pointed out. I was also reminded that people sometimes "daven" a Gemara, something I remember kids doing. Good point. It's just....it's weird.
Tefillin blog
Monday, August 08, 2005
The F word
In theory, all religious fundamentalists claim that their beliefs are grounded in Scripture or other sacred texts. In practice, however, such groups come over time to propound a fixed list of beliefs or "traditions", each one individually considered a sine qua non for remaining acceptable with the group (and thereby to God!). Because it is unwavering acquiescence to their own system of beliefs and practices that is required membership in the group itself is not grounded upon a rational or intellectual basis, but is actually determined primarily by a combination of psycho-sociological and/ or political factors. Criticisms of group leadership of questions about group values and customs are disallowed and regarded as dangerous or sinful. Thus, to be or to remain a "member", one....must adhere faithfully both to all tenets collectively, and also to each tenet individually, because every single tenet is perceived as one of the foundational = "fundamental", hence essential, truths."If the shoe fits...
For example, the Torah-only issue. If the Torah and halakha is meant to regulate a living society then it follows that halakha expects there to be Jewish doctors and lawyers and gardners and electricians and poets and thousands of other things that any society must have. Yet according to the tenets of some Jewish fundamentalists none of these pursuits are even possible according to the values of these fundamentalists.
Or the dress issue. In theory, most Jewish fundamentalists will acknowledge, a person can be an oved Hashem and wear blue shirts. Yet in principle one cannot really belong to the group and hence not really the best Jew one could be if one wears blue shirts. A list could be expanded of "tenets" that are NOT essential to Judaism but are essential to a certain type of Jewish fundamentalism.
What of listing concrete proofs in the form of great historical rabbis of impeccable reputation who deviated from the present-day values and tenets of this form of Jewish fundamentalism?
To no avail; according to another (unwritten) "tenet", great rabbis provide exceptions rather than rules.
For example, it is obvious that R. Avigdor Miller z"l read extensively in many heretical disciplines, including the holy books of other religions. I once tried to cite R. Miller as 'proof' that one could read such material, at least to fulfull "da ma she-tashiv". The response I get was fahkert, R. Miller could read it but we can't. This isn't different than the idea that "RSRH could say it, but we can't".
Or the fact that R. Saadya Ga'on outlined four principles by which a person may reject the literal meaning of scripture is taken only as proof that a Ga'on may do so but not "us".
The word is a description and not a value judgement. Unfortunately the fundamentalist label applies to groups who fight holy wars against innocents and men who abuse large numbers of women and children as well as people who only want to do their own thing without harming anyone. Since that's the case it is no wonder that fundamentalists themselves have no wish to be counted with some really harmful people. And yet, fundamentalism isn't definitionally about causing bloodshed--it's just that some fundamentalists cause harm while others do not.
Could the biblical Isaiah have understood Ivrit?
A non-ideological objection comes from Israeli linguist Ghil'ad Zuckermann, whose thesis is that modern Ivrit is more accurately a hybrid, both Semitic and Indo-European, thus, the term Israeli is far more appropriate [a name] than "Israeli Hebrew".
In his controversial paper, he writes that
The Mutual Intelligibility Assumption posits that Israeli is Hebrew because an Israeli speaker can understand Hebrew. Edward Ullendorff has claimed that the biblical Isaiah could have understood Israeli. I am not convinced that this would have been the case. The reason Israelis can be expected to understand the book of Isaiah – albeit still with difficulties – is surely because they study the Old Testament at school for eleven years, rather than because it is familiar to them from their daily conversation. Furthermore, Israelis read the bible as if it were Israeli and often therefore misunderstand it. When an Israeli reads y?led sha‘ashu‘?m in Jeremiah 31:19 (King James 20), s/he does not understand it as ‘pleasant child’ but rather as ‘playboy’. Ba’u banim ‘ad mashber in Isaiah 37:3 is interpreted by Israelis as ‘children arrived at a crisis’ rather than as ‘children arrived at the mouth of the womb, to be born’. The available examples are not only lexical: much more importantly, Israelis are often incapable of recognizing moods, aspects and tenses in the Bible.Languagehat quotes more from the paper. Very interesting topic. Especially (to me) the intriguing part I italicized. What about the reverse? And what, if anything, does that say about the nature of Ivrit?
One more excerpt
Yet, Israeli children are told that the Old Testament was written in their mother tongue. In other words, in Israeli primary schools, Hebrew and Israeli are, axiomatically, the very same. One cannot therefore expect Israelis easily to accept the idea that the two languages might be genetically different. In English terms, it is as if someone were to try to tell a native English-speaker that his/her mother tongue is not the same as Shakespeare’s. The difference is that between Shakespeare and the current native speaker of English there has been a continuous chain of native speakers. Between the biblical Isaiah and contemporary Israelis there has been no such chain, while the Jews have had many mother tongues other than Hebrew...I think the difference that Zuckermann posits is a chiluk that stands on a very thin wire. Hebrew did develop over the centuries organically, albeit in a more limited way than if it had remained a spoken, native language.
On the Main Line, now with tags: Hebrew
Buying tzoah shel-sora
But is there a way to test if an anecdote might be true without really knowing the facts?
Biblical scholars looking to find the historical Jesus buried within the Greek Testament realize that most of the material just lionizes him and is only useful in telling us what people who esteemed him thought about him. But the rule they use is that details in the text that jump at us because it seems so out of character provide clues that are likely to be authentic. Thus, if he is said to be a carpenter than he probably was, after all the people who elevated a man into a god weren't likely to have invented a humble profession for him. If the text has him saying something harsh, something that doesn't seem very sar shalom-like, then he probably said it too.
I don't know how useful that really is, but there you have it.
Recently someone mentioned of the Klauzenberger Rebbe z"l the following:
The kloisenberger rebbe went through many incomprehensibly painfull years in the consentration camp. The 1st thing he did when freed was jump into a river, to be toivel the first time in years. To the people who started straying after they where freed, he said , if this is how you act, better you would have been killed in the camps.That someone put those words into the mouth of the holy rebbe of Klauzenberg blew my mind. That statement is very cruel. The rebbe was not only not a cruel person, on the contrary!--he was a paragon of righteousness and is known specifically for being a comfort and source of strength to survivors in the immediate aftermath of the war--even as he lost a wife and ten children. To me it is inconceivable that he'd have said the thing attributed to him. I do not accept it, and not only because it is yet another one of the unreliable stories about rabbis that float around. It would really distress me if in 1900 years from now scholars would take the statement attributed to him as true precisely because it is uncharacteristic of him, but I digress.
It's a strange thing, in any case, that a person would believe that he said it and not only believe that he said it but agree with it because he said it. How could a person not see that to say this thing is cruel? The answer is as follows: some people do not think critically and they work bckwards. If such-and-such is known to be a tzaddik then it doesn't matter what anyone has the tzaddik doing. If he acts inappropriately, if he even acts with cruelty then by definition the action is still blameless and no one should question it. This is exactly why certain rabbinic personalities of recent decades who said really terrible things about people they opposed got away with it.
Friday, August 05, 2005
How did you learn to read Hebrew?
* He was a wonderful rebbe.
Rashi Wein
Rabbi [Berel] Wein estimated that 80% of Ashkenazi Jewry is descended from Rashi. Michael Gerver's calculations led him to believe that the percentage was somewhat higher.Is that even a remotely plausible statement? It sounds really, really off to me. I honestly don't know what to make of it.

