Monday, May 09, 2005

Who's the nimrod?

One of the irksome slanders some highly frummer-than-thou anti-Zionist Jews proclaim about Israelis is that their language and names are Jewishly illegitimate. Oft-mentioned is a legendary Israeli named Nimrod. Nimrod was a Biblical despot whose very name connotes rebellions [against God]. Thus the modern Nimrods (conveniently no one can tell you exactly who is named Nimrod; there is only the assertion that Nimrods exist) are supposed to be proof that Israeli Jews are a) Biblically illiterate b) hostile to God and Torah and c) perverters of 'Lashon ha-qodesh'.

Google nimrod raphaeli iraqi jew and the myth is lain to rest. Whether or not a good Jewish boy should be named Nimrod (the Talmud discourages naming a baby for a wicked person) the Dr. Nimrod Raphaeli, an Iraqi-born Jew, demonstrates this particular myth to be compete bunk, much like a lot of anti-Zionist hooey stemming from religious opposition.

Tuesday, May 03, 2005

Fantastic aggadah

The Jewish Worker writes on the non-literal interpretation of aggadah:

The gemara at the end of berachos (54b) has a bizarre story about Og. The gemara describes how Og had planned to destroy Israel. He planned to uproot a mountain three miles in size, throw it upon them and kill them. The gemara then goes on to describe how Moshe killed Og. I am not the one who calls this wild. The Maharsha comments on this story "זר הוא" that the story is bizarre. The Maharsha then proceeds to quote a Rashba who interpreted the story allegorically and the Maharsha himself offers a differetn allegorical interpretation.

We see from here that we not every statement of Chazal needs to be taken literally.

I would respectfully point out that I don't think we need to hide behind the coattails of the Maharsha and Rashba to take a tale of a giant uprooting a three mile mountain as an allegory.

I understand that JW's point is merely to cite a prooftext for the literalists, but we see from the story itself that not every statement of Chazal needs to be taken literally! People that would require a Maharsha to tell them this are, frankly, setting their brain to "low".

About those fantastic aggados

The Jewish Worker writes on the non-literal interpretation of aggadah:

The gemara at the end of berachos (54b) has a bizarre story about Og. The gemara describes how Og had planned to destroy Israel. He planned to uproot a mountain three miles in size, throw it upon them and kill them. The gemara then goes on to describe how Moshe killed Og. I am not the one who calls this wild. The Maharsha comments on this story "זר הוא" that the story is bizarre. The Maharsha then proceeds to quote a Rashba who interpreted the story allegorically and the Maharsha himself offers a differetn allegorical interpretation.

We see from here that we not every statement of Chazal needs to be taken literally.

I would respectfully point out that I don't think we need to hide behind the coattails of the Maharsha and Rashba to take a tale of a giant uprooting a three mile mountain as an allegory.

I understand that JW's point is merely to cite a prooftext for the literalists, but we see from the story itself that not every statement of Chazal needs to be taken literally! People that would require a Maharsha to tell them this are, frankly, setting their brain to "low".

Tuesday, March 29, 2005

The Prophet Milton (PBUH)

For no other reason than that it bugs me, here I protest against the Anglicizing of personal names of people in Jewish history. I understand why Biblical personalities are Anglicized. That is how they are popularly known. But why would a 3rd century amora like Shmuel need to be called Samuel, when in fact few outside of scholarly circles would have heard of him in any case? Why does Moshe ben Maimon have to be called Moses ben Maimon? Why is the Maharal known as Judah Loew and not Yehuda Loew? The Vilna Gaon is R. Elijah instead of R. Eliyahu. The Hafetz Hayyim is called R. Israel Meir ha-Cohen, as if great confusion will result if he is called R. Yisrael Meir ha-Cohen instead. Can it be that people will be so perplexed at the unfamiliar form that they must be condescended to? I doubt it. Who would think to call Gorbachev "Michael"? Or Muhammad "Milton" (or Mahomet)?

On the other hand, if they were known in their own time by another form, ala R. Moses Feinstein (see his stationary) I guess it's no big deal (as is, ultimately, the whole problem of Anglicizing names -- I just want to be annoyed at things sometimes).

Sunday, March 20, 2005

Genesis 12:6 "And the Canaanites were then in the land."
1) Aryeh Kaplan’s Living Torah – nothing
2) Hertz – “i.e., was already in the land. ‘Before the Age of Abraham the Canaanites had already settled in the lowlands of Palestine—Canaan, be it noted, signified Lowlands (Sayce). The interpretation of this verse as meaning that the Canaanites were at that time in the land, but were no longer so at the time when Genesis was written (an interpretation which misled even Ibn Ezra) is quite impossible. The Canaanites formed part of the population down to the days of the later Kings.
3) Artscroll - nothing

Gen: 14:14 "he pursued them as far as Dan"
1) Aryeh Kaplan - "A city at the northern end of the Holy Land, 12 miles north of Lake Hula, and 120 miles north of Hebron. It may have been called that since it would later be named Dan, or else there may have been an ancient city there by that name (Radak). Targum Yonathan identifies it as Dan of Caesarea, since Caesarea was some three miles to the east of Dan. (See Joshua 19:47, Judges 18:29). Saadia identifies it with the Banias River."
2) Hertz - The name is given to the place by anticipation. Formerly it was called Leshem (Josh. 19:47) or Laish (Judg. 18:29). It is in the extreme of Northern Palestine.
3) Artscroll – At Dan, in the north of Eretz Yisrael, Abraham’s strength ebbed because he foresaw prophetically that his descendants would set up a calf there as an idol [I Kings 12:29] (Rashi). This is one of many instances in the Torah where future events have an effect on current history. The sense of this phenomenon is that the potential for the future is contained in the present; if there was idolatry in Abraham’s offspring, it indicated an insufficiency in him.

By the way, what is “current history”?

Genesis 36:31 "Now these were the kings who reigned in the land of Edom before any king reigned over the children of Israel".
1) Aryeh Kaplan "Simply, this means that these kings reigned long before there was a king in Israel. Many commentaries, however, state that the first king of Israel alluded to in this verse is Moses (cf. Deuteronomy 33:5; Rashbam; Ibn Ezra; Ralbag). We do, however, find that there were Edomite kings contemporary to Moses (Numbers 20:14). Therefore, it must be said that Moses was not considered a king until the concept of a king was given to the Israelites (Deuteronomy 17:15). It also appears that the chiefs (alufim) ruled over Edom right after the Exodus (cf. Exodus 15:15), but the kings may have reigned concurrently (see Mekhilta on Exodus 15:14; but see Ramban on Genesis 36:40). Of course, if the alufim are seen as tribes (see Genesis 36:40), this does not present any problem. There is a tradition that the Edomite kings began to reign 550 years before the first Israelite king (Rabenu Chananel, quoted in Bachya on Genesis 32:16). Since Saul, the first king of Israel, took his throne in 2882 (879 b.c.e.), this would mean that Edom's kingdom began 550 years earlier in 2332 (1429 b.c.e.). This was the year that Levi died, and it is well established that Levi was the last of Jacob's sons to die. Thus, there may have been a tradition that Esau's kingdom did not begin during the lifetime of any of Jacob's sons. There is, however, a conflicting tradition that the reign of Bela (Genesis 36:32) began in 2258, twenty years after Jacob came to Egypt (see note on Genesis 36:32)."
2) Hertz – This verse raises an obvious difficulty. Ibn Ezra understands the ‘king’ to refer to Moses, the ruler of the Children of Israel. A more satisfactory explanation of the verse is the following. In the last chapter there had been an emphatic promise from God Almighty to Jacob that ‘kings shall come out of thy loins’. The Israelites, no doubt, cherished a constant hope of such a kingdom and such a kingly race. Moses himself (Deut. 28:36) prophesied concerning the king whom the Israelites would set over them; and hence it was not unnatural that, when recording the eight kings who reigned in the family of Esau up to his own time, Scripture should go out of its way to reassure the Israelites that their history was not yet complete. The words in the Hebrew are, ‘before the reigning of a king to the sons of Israel’; and it might be rendered ‘whilst as yet the children of Israel have no king’; there being nothing in the words expressive of past tense, or indicating that, before they were written, a king had reigned in Israel.
3) Artscroll – Rashi cites this verse as an example of the prophecy given to Rebecca that ‘the might shall pass from one of them to the other (25:23), meaning that the two brothers would not both be great simultaneously. Thus, when Esau had kings, Israel had none, and when Israel rose up, Esau declined, and his kings were defeated by Israel. (there's more elaboration on this theme, about the state of the Jews in 2000 years of galut, but it is pretty tangential to the issue in question and I'm tired of typing! also note the asymmetry in Artscroll's elaboration on Rashi's peshat.)

Friday, March 26, 2004

[archive] Hapax legomena

HAPAX LEGOMENA (Gr. "once said"), words which are only once recorded in a certain kind of literature. Since the interest in Middle Hebrew lexicography arose comparatively late, Middle Hebrew texts are frequently not well-established philologically and new texts are often discovered, the interest in hapax legomena in Hebrew is, for all practical purposes, limited to the Bible or, more precisely, to biblical Hebrew. There are in biblical Hebrew about 1,300 hapax legomena (yet their precise number cannot be stated, since the exact definition is not clear as to whether or not they include homonymic hapax legomena). Most of them (about 900) are not too difficult to interpret, being derived from well-known biblical roots (as emdah, Micah 1:11, moomad, Ps. 69:3, both denoting "standing ground," being derived from the well-known root dmA, "to stand"). About 400, however, cannot be derived from known biblical roots and are therefore more difficult to interpret. Occurring only once, their exact meaning is more difficult to establish from context than that of words attested more often. Except for this fact and the possibility that hapax legomena may have arisen through error in transmission, the philological treatment of hapax legomena does not differ from that of words occurring more often. The meaning of both is elucidated by comparison with other Semitic languages, which often makes it possible to establish the etymology of the word treated. Middle Hebrew has, of course, a special standing in this matter. Since the Bible, because of its small size and limited topics, has preserved only a small part of Hebrew vocabulary, it is often due to mere chance that a word occurs only once in the Bible, though there may be ample examples of it in Middle Hebrew (as in the case with sullam "ladder," Gen. 28:12). Even the sages of the Mishnah did not understand the hapax legomenon we-tetetiha, "and I will sweep it" (Isa. 14:23), except with the help of vernacular speech, as used by Rabbi's handmaid (RH 26b). Hapax legomena sometimes belong to removed subject matters (as Isa. 3:18ff., describing the ornaments of Zion's daughters), and there are relatively many hapax legomena denoting animals, plants, and diseases (as leta$ah "lizard," Lev. 11:30; luz, "almond tree," Gen. 30:37; harhur, "fever," Deut. 28:22) and loan words (as appiryon, "litter," Song 3:9). The Book of Job, with its special style and many Aramaisms, contains a relatively large proportion of hapax legomena, 145 in number, among them 60 without derivation from known biblical roots. The (much larger) Book of Isaiah has 201 hapax legomena, among them, again, 60 without derivation.

In Hebrew literature hapax legomena are called en lo ah, en lo haver, en lo rea ba-Miqra, "it has nothing alike, no brother, no fellow, no comrade in the Bible," or millim bodedot, "isolated words." Saadiah Gaon wrote in Arabic Kitab al-Sabin Lafza min Mufradat al-Quran ("The Book of Seventy Hapax Legomena in the Bible"), dealing with over 90 (!) hapax legomena, which he explains by means of mishnaic words. It stands to reason that this book originally contained 70 words, and was expanded later, either by Saadiah himself or by others, yet preserving its original name. Although it is one of the oldest and most important philological works in the history of Hebrew linguistics, it is in its intention a polemic work against Karaites, endeavoring to prove the value of tradition from the linguistic point of view: without mishnaic Hebrew even the linguistic interpretation of the Bible is impossible.
[Joshua Blau]

From EJ

Saturday, March 13, 2004

...

Yehudah Levi

HALACHIC DECISIONS

CLASSIC ISSUES WITH MODERN IMPLICATIONS

It Was Not Always Thus

Nowadays, when you ask a learned friend a halacha question, the response is likely to be: “This is subject to disagreement among the authorities.” If you then ask, “So what am I supposed to do?” he will tell you, “Go ask your rabbi.” And when you do that, the answer may well depend on which rabbi you happen to ask. This is the unfortunate situation today.

But it was not always so. Two thou­sand years ago it was different, as the Talmud teaches us:

At first, there were not many [halachic] disputes in [the nation of] Israel. The [High] Court of seventy-one sat in the Lishkas Hagazis (the High Court room in the Temple precinct).... When a question arose.. ..they put the question before them. If they had a tra­dition concerning it, they responded accordingly. If not, they [debated the issue and] voted on it [and decided according to the majority]. When the disciples of Shammai and Hillel, who did not study sufficiently, became many, unresolved disputes increased in Israel, and the Torah became like two Toros (Sanhedrin 88b).

Elsewhere it explains: “When men of arrogance multiplied, unresolved disputes increased in Israel” {Sota 47b). Clearly, the increase in unresolved dis­putes was due to the unwillingness of the proponents of a particular idea to hear, and duly consider, the opponents’ opinion. Evidently, they were so self-assured that they saw no need to seri­ously consider the opposing view.

This idea helps us resolve an appar­ently strange Talmudic statement:

For three years, Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel were disputing; these said the halacha is according to us, and those said the halacha is according to us. Then a Heavenly Voice appeared, and said, “These and those are the words of the living G-d, and the halacha is according to Beis Hillel” (Eiruvin 13b).

The Talmud then asks - and answers:

If, indeed, “These and those are the words of the living G-d,” how did Beis Hillel merit that the halacha was fixed according to them? Because they were amiable and forgiving, and [always] presented their ideas together with that of Beis Shammai, and even presented Beis Shammai’s opinion first.

On first sight, this passage is strange - is, then, halacha fixed according to the proponent’s personality merits, rather than according to the merits of his opinion? After all, it is known that Beis Shammai were intellectually superior. This question brings to mind the Mishna, “Who is wise? He who learns from everyone” {Avos 4:1). No one - not even the wisest person - can think of every aspect of an issue. Only after hearing other opinions can we arrive at a balanced judgment – “Success comes from the multiplicity of advi­sors” (Mishlei 11,14). This explains why, with all the importance of sharpness of intellect, a willingness to listen is even more important to arriving at the cor­rect decision.

Rabbi Zalman Nechemia Goldberg[1] points out that the above Talmudic state­ment hints at the fact that Beis Hillel did not finalize their opinion until they had heard that of Beis Shammai. With this concept, he resolves another halachic principle which seems strange on first sight. When the three judges of a rabbinic court are divided, with two in favor of Reuven and one against him, the case is decided in favor of Reuven. If, however, the third judge does not rule against Reuven, but rather is unable to form an opinion, then the case is not decided in favor of Reuven. Instead, two more judges must be added to the court, which must then continue its deliberations. Again, listening to an opposing opinion is more constructive than hearing no opinion.

Thus, the fact that the High Court, from the generation following Hillel and Shammai and onwards, did not convene for halachic decision-making, has given rise to a halachic pluralism. This is certainly undesirable, but we must learn to live with it; that is, we must become tolerant of authorities with different views. This is how the Chazon Ish put it (Yoreh De’ah 150):

It seems that the rule “in Torah matters [in contrast to Rabbinic decrees] follow the more stringent opinion” applies only when none of [the ruling sages] is his rabbi, but if one of the authorities is his rabbi, follow him even [if he is] lenient. And he is called his rabbi if he is close to him and constantly studies his teachings in most com­mandments. …And this applies both during this authority’s lifetime and after his demise, as long as his deci­sions and instructions are known from his disciples or his books. They may follow their rabbi even [if he is] lenient in Torah matters - even if the majority disagrees with him, as long as there was no court session, with the authorities discussing the matter face-to-face, deciding the halacha.

One more important point. Because of yeridas hadoros (decline of generations), it may, at this point, be impossible to elimi­nate halachic and ideological disagreement between various segments of the Jewish people. However, we should remember: Although the disciples of Shammai and Hillel were unable to settle their disagree­ments, “they treated each other with love and friendship” (Yevamos 14b). We would do well to follow their example. This is especially important today, when Divine Providence is hinting to us that redemption may not be far off – provided we permit it to come, by eliminating unjustified hatred from our midst.[2]

Beyond the Guidelines

When halacha authorities devi­ate from these guidelines, the results can be very destructive. The reader, especially if he has spent time in Eretz Yisroel, is likely to be familiar with illustrations, such as huge posters, “signed” by great Torah authorities, plastered all over walls and bulletin boards, attacking actions that were approved by other Torah authori­ties – and attacking them in the most extreme and virulent terms, without ever having discussed the matter with approving authorities, or even mention­ing these – leaving the general public confused, if not worse. Or, on a differ­ent plane, I recall talking to an editor of Agudath Israel’s newspaper Hamodia, who mourned the vanishing of Chinuch Atzmai, where children from all circles of Torah Judaism learned together. His complaint: “Now every group opens its own chadarim, the tragic result being that the children of one group develop utter disdain for all other groups.” He sighed: “I have a little nephew who looks upon me as a goy.”

A hundred years ago, the founders of Agudath Israel showed the way by convening the spiritual leaders of almost all factions of European Torah Jewry and establishing a Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah representing all of these factions. This could be termed the major accomplish­ment of twentieth century Judaism. How sad that in the last generation, it was made to fall apart - at least in Eretz Yisroel.

Let us remember the beautiful description Chazal give us (end of Ta’anis) of the tzaddikim in Gan Eden: Hashem will place them in a circle around Him, and each tzaddik will point at Him with his finger, exclaiming: "This is my G-d; let us rejoice in His salva­tion." Clearly, each one is pointing in a different direction!

True,.when differing ideologies are crowded together in close proximity, showing mutual respect is more of a challenge. But this may be taken as an advantage in the spirit of the Mishna (Avos 5, end): “According to the pain (=effort) is the reward (=benefit).” This crowding forces each group to answer questions that their adherents raise, to justify itself to its adherents, and as a result, the issues become clarified. Resorting to labeling, instead, is much, much easier, but also far less constructive - to put it mildly.

Another point: before we disqualify any idea as totally out of bounds, we should first make sure that not one accepted authority supported it.

Whom are we to blame for this sad state of affairs? Our Sages teach: “The [level of the] leader is [determined by] the [level of the] generation” (Arachin 17a). The obvious message is: let us become more tolerant of each other, and let us try to understand each other, and not reject any Torah Jew without a sincere effort to clarify the issues that create a chasm between us.

_______________________________

Yehudah (Leo) Levi received hetteh hora’a from Rabbi Yoseif Breuer זצ"ל and Rabbi Yitzchok Hutner זצ"ל. He is rector emeritus of the Jerusalem College of Technology, where he founded the Physics and Elector-optics Department in 1970, and is still giving regu­lar courses in Torah thought. In addition to 130-odd articles published in scientific, technical and Judaica journals, Prof. Levi has published a number of books in optics, as well as in halacha, including a new commentary on Yerushalmi Zeraim (six tractates have been published so far – four with Rabbi Aryeh Carmell and two with Rabbi Gershon Metzger).



[1] Rabbi Goldberg, the son-in-law of Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, is Rosh Yeshiva of Machon Lev, Rosh Kollel Zadiguria in Jerusalem, and sits on the Israel Rabbinic High Court. After publishing the above idea in HaMa’ayan (453.68), I received a letter from him, citing the supporting ideas presented in the following.

[2] As the Rav of Brisk, Rabbi Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik put it: “When the United Nations agreed to the State’s founding, Divine Providence smiled, but those in power spoiled the smile.” (Quoted by Rabbi Shlomo Wolbe, Bein Sheishes Le'Asor, p. 145.) Also, the Sanctuary was destroyed because of unjustified hatred between Jews (Yoma 9b), and it stands to reason that it cannot be rebuilt as long as the cause for its destruction still exists (cf. Sanhedrin 97b, end).


The Jewish Observer, January/ February 2006

Wednesday, April 23, 2003

Living Torah Museum - BAR article

(cont.) When he was older, he visited museums around the world, from the Louvre in Paris to the Israel Museum in Jerusalem.

Finally, he created the Living Torah Museum above the room that serves as the synagogue, or shul (the shtibl) that he leads. (He lives with his wife and five children in other rooms in the building.) One room of the museum is devoted to the Biblical period; the other, to the Second Temple and Rabbinic periods.

His is a teaching museum. When the holy text refers to a sword or a coin or a lamp or a seal, Rabbi Deutsch wants to show people what it looked like. He isn’t much concerned with exact dating—as long as the artifact illustrates what the text is referring to. The labels in the vitrines have no dates attached to them. But he does have one rule: No replicas. All the artifacts in the museum must be the real thing. The only exception is a tiny replica of the Rosetta Stone from the British Museum, which was the basis for deciphering hieroglyphics.

Rabbi Deutsch went about assembling the items in his museum in the only way he knew: Go to the most reputable antiquities dealers and follow their advice. He also has a number of museum-quality pieces on loan from well-known collectors. He estimates the market value of the pieces in his museum to be about a million dollars. The museum also has a small, but quite sophisticated research library: the holy books on one side, the archaeological tomes on the other.

He also has plans for the future. He dreams of a six-story building on a piece of land the community owns behind the present building. For this, he estimates, he needs between 15 and 20 million dollars. Will he get it? “Oh yes,” he says, “It’s just a matter of time.”

He says he has had no opposition from the observant, devout community in which he lives. Yeshiva students (a yeshiva is a traditional rabbinic academy) are flocking to the museum, he says. He recalls for them a passage or an episode from the holy texts and then points to the item that is being referred to in the text. That is what he wants to do, he says: to teach Torah (in its broadest sense, all religious learning) through archaeology. Even the heads of leading yeshivot have come to see and admire his museum, he says.

Talmudic law requires an exceptionally sharp blade to be used in the kosher slaughter of animals. A sharp knife of obsidian (a type of glass) qualifies. But what if the sharp obsidian is still part of a formation in the ground, a Talmudic discussion asks. Can you slaughter the animal by drawing the animal’s neck across the stationary obsidian? One rabbi says no, but the rule is that the animal is validly slaughtered; it is kosher. Rabbi Deutsch displays a lump of obsidian to illustrate what the rabbinic text is talking about when it refers to something attached to the ground.

Another Talmudic discussion involves a situation in which vermin is found in one’s clothes on the Sabbath. Can one “press” (that is, kill) the vermin on the Sabbath, when “work” is forbidden? Some rabbis would do so and some would not. Raba, however, would throw the vermin into a likna of water instead of “pressing” them. What is a likna? Readers familiar with Greek pottery vessels will recognize in this rabbinic term a lekanis, a footed bowl with a cover, often beautifully decorated. With the cover on the lekanis, the vermin could not escape and would drown in the water. But the Sabbath prohibition would not be violated. Rabbi Deutsch can show his visitors what a likna/lekanis looks like.

Two things are not in Rabbi Deutsch’s museum—figurines or altars. Rabbi Deutsch does not want the museum to be offensive to strictly Orthodox Jews, he says. Figurines might be associated with idol worship. I asked him about human figures depicted on the coins on display. Only three-dimensional images are forbidden, he said.

Rabbi Deutsch emphasizes that he welcomes to his museum not only all Jews, regardless of how observant or unobservant, but non-Jews as well.

Rabbi Deutsch is, as you might expect, very knowledgeable archaeologically. He is well aware of the “forgery frenzy” now going on in Israel. I asked him if he was worried about forgeries. He said that he must rely on the most reputable antiquities dealers (some in the archaeological establishment would say this is an oxymoron). He told me that when three items were recently questioned, he took them off display.

He also displays some items with provenance; he knows where they came from. One of the prize pieces in his museum, he says, is the oldest complete copy of the Ten Commandments—well, actually, 11 commandments. They are the Samaritan version, which includes an extra commandment. And, well, the complete text has not survived. And we’re not sure of the date. The plaque on which the commandments are inscribed was allegedly found in 1913 near Yavneh in the course of excavations to build the Palestine-Egypt railway.

There is a certain sweetness in the rabbi’s naivete, and, at the same time, a justifiable pride in his accomplishment. He has done what no one else in the United States (perhaps in the world outside of Israel) has done. With all the interest in the Bible, with all the interest in archaeology, no one else has done it. Maybe someone else would do it better, but all the big shots, all the people with access to the most sophisticated knowledge and current excavations, have not accomplished what Rabbi Deutsch has done. His is a teaching museum. When the holy text refers to a sword or a coin or a lamp or a seal, Rabbi Deutsch wants to show people what it looked like. He isn’t much concerned with exact dating—as long as the artifact illustrates what the text is referring to. The labels in the vitrines have no dates attached to them. But he does have one rule: No replicas. All the artifacts in the museum must be the real thing. The only exception is a tiny replica of the Rosetta Stone from the British Museum, which was the basis for deciphering hieroglyphics.

Rabbi Deutsch went about assembling the items in his museum in the only way he knew: Go to the most reputable antiquities dealers and follow their advice. He also has a number of museum-quality pieces on loan from well-known collectors. He estimates the market value of the pieces in his museum to be about a million dollars. The museum also has a small, but quite sophisticated research library: the holy books on one side, the archaeological tomes on the other.

He also has plans for the future. He dreams of a six-story building on a piece of land the community owns behind the present building. For this, he estimates, he needs between 15 and 20 million dollars. Will he get it? “Oh yes,” he says, “It’s just a matter of time.”

He says he has had no opposition from the observant, devout community in which he lives. Yeshiva students (a yeshiva is a traditional rabbinic academy) are flocking to the museum, he says. He recalls for them a passage or an episode from the holy texts and then points to the item that is being referred to in the text. That is what he wants to do, he says: to teach Torah (in its broadest sense, all religious learning) through archaeology. Even the heads of leading yeshivot have come to see and admire his museum, he says.

Wednesday, February 05, 2003

Abietes
Abraeus
Abraham
Adaeus
Ananias
Arsamos
Arsamos
Baneas
Baseas
Chabrias
Chabu
Dakis
Daniel
Dathaeus
Dositheus
Eleazar
Eleazar
Elisha
Elisha
Elisha
Endemias
Eschlemias
Ezekiah
Ezekiah
Ezekiel
Isaac
Isaac
Isaelus
Jacob
Jacob
Jason
Jason
Jesias
Jeremiah
Jesus
Jesus
John
John
John
Jonathan
Jonathan
Jonathes
Joseph
Joseph
Joseph
Joseph
Judas
Judas
Judas
Levi
Mattathias
Natthaeus
Nehemiah
Ornias
Sabbataeus
Sabbataeus
Samuel
Samuel
Samuel
Selemias
Simon
Simon
Simon
Theodosius
Theodosius
Theodotus
Theophilus
Zachariah
Zachariah
Zacharias
Zedekiah

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails
'