Monday, June 18, 2007

R David Cohen's thesis on the origin of Yiddish is limited by lack of evidence.

R. David Cohen has an interesting work (אברהם יגל יצחק ירנן) with the thesis that the emergence of Judaic languages like Yiddish and Ladino can be explained in light of passages in rabbinic literature like the following:

תלמוד ירושלמי מסכת שבת פרק א הלכה ד
מה דתני רשב"י בו ביום גזרו על...ועל לשונן

"That which R. Shim`on ben Yohai has taught: 'On that day they made a decree against [list of things]...and their language."

This speaks of a rabbinic decree opposing non-Jewish language (in a list of prohibitions including things like bread, cheese, wine, etc.).

In support he cites

שו"ת חתם סופר חלק ד (אה"ע ב) סימן יא
ולדעתי גם הקדמוני' היו בקיאי' ללועזי' בלע"ז אך בכוונה שבשו הלשונות מפני גזירת י"ח דבר שבירושלמי פ"ק דשבת דפוס וויען דף וי"ו /ו'/ ע"א ועל לשונם יע"ש ואין להאריך בזה בעו"ה
This is an attempt to account for this phenomenon. The Chasam Sofer opines that the 'correct' vernacular was known to those of earlier generations. However, they deliberately distorted it in their use of it in speech, in line with the Yerushalmi quoted above.

Indeed, the possibility of people knowing how to wield a 'proper' and an ethnic dialect of the same language at the same time is well documented and needs no elaboration here.

Thus, R. Cohen's thesis that the emergence of Yiddish and Ladino can be explained in this fashion. I believe what you have here is a classic syllogism, which is to say, that the juxtaposition of two facts (premises) are made to produce a third, previously unknown fact. In this case, the facts are

1. Yiddish and Ladino are different from German and Spanish
2. There is a rabbinic prohibition on the use of non-Jewish languages

and the result is

3. The rabbis deliberately spoke and promulgated distorted versions of the local vernaculars, and thereby is explained the emergence of Yiddish and Ladino.

Whether or not this is true is a historical question cannot be resolved by linking a 'fact' (this belongs in quotes, as I shall explain) with another fact.

The problems:

While Yiddish is different from German (and Ladino from Spanish), how different was Yiddish from the German of the time of its inception? To what extent has the development of Yiddish in non-German speaking lands influenced its divergence from German? To what extent has non Germanic languages influenced Yiddish? What of the status of dialects within a single geographical area 1000 years ago? Apparently persons living in European villages speaking dialects cultivated locally were often unable to understand people who spoke different dialects of the same language only one hundred miles away. Which German did Yiddish derive from and diverge from? What about the relationship between Ladino and Spanish? Between other Judeo dialects? Babylonian Aramaic? Palestinian Aramaic? What of Rashi's use of 'לע"ז,' which happens to be one of the most important extant source for Old French? Presumably these correct French words were being addressed to Jews for whom it was the vernacular. What of Judeo-Arabic? Suppose some counter examples are shown; perhaps only Yiddish and German (intentionally) adhered to the prohibition in the Yerushami?

These are all questions which can be answered only by examining old German literature and old Yiddish literature (actually, Yiddish literature makes a late appearance relative to the time which it probably emerged) as well as other materials which address the state of language in the Middle Ages. For example, while it is true that the German which is presently spoken is quite different from Yiddish, Yiddish itself is not so different from the strata known as Middle High German, which is the German that Yiddish emerged from, just as modern German emerged from it. That's why I placed 'fact' in inverted commas above.

However, R. Cohen's study ignores these various pieces of evidence which may be marshaled to prove or disprove the thesis. And it is a pity, because there is an enormous (even if insufficient) body of evidence to examine. But by eschewing it in favor of an interpretation of a Yerushalmi, combined with an apparent fact and supported by a Chasam Sofer (who failed to show that the 'correct' vernaculars were available all along) may have resulted in the historical truth of the emergence of Judeo languages, but it also might not have.

Indeed, for the second half of Yiddish's history, when it migrated eastward from Germany, it is an apparent fact that unlike the other places where Jews lived they did not adopt the local vernaculars, but continued speaking their own (until the well documented struggles over this issue in the 18th and 19th century). This might well be a fact worth examining in partial support of R. Cohen's thesis. It would not show that such languages were deliberately created from on high for the masses (can such a thing be? Maybe--`Ivrit?) but it might show that a conscious effort to adhere to the prohibition in the Yerushalmi. On the other hand, other factors, such as the ghettoization of the population might be the cause.

This particular thesis was cited in this letter in Jewish Action. I think there is something of a shame that both the writer of this letter and the author of the work that was the subject of this post are brilliant. But a question such as this can't be resolved by ignoring all the available evidence in favor of syllogism. Indeed, sometimes all there is is thin evidence and the only way to arrive at a working theory is through exegesis. If the only evidence appertaining to the rise of Yiddish and Ladino were the Yerushalmi and the Chasam Sofer and a few slivers of other sources I'd understand and accept such a theory.

Logical inferences are very useful in producing important new thoughts, but we all know that sitting in one's study and logically proving that the planets and stars must be attached to concentric spheres is ultimately self-limiting when one can also gaze into a telescope.

Thursday, June 14, 2007

A jubilant alternative to the Torah from antiquity?

One of the Jewish apocryphal books from the 2nd Temple period is Jubilees.

In an article called The Book of "Jubilees" and the Pentateuch by Solomon Zeitlin, New Ser., Vol. 48, No. 2, Dropsie College Jubilee Alumni Issue. (Oct., 1957), pp. 218-235--read it here--the hypothesis is put forth that this book--which reviews quite a bit of the Torah's narrative with important differences.

His contention is that this book is actually intended as an alternative to the Torah. (Perhaps that sounds milder if we call it Pentateuch?) In other words, it appears to be an alternative telling of the history of the Jewish people, the Avoth, Egypt, Exodus, etc. It knows of the age-old Jewish practices, its festivals, etc. but it gives different reasons for them. For example, it has Avraham instituting Sukkot:

Jub. 16:26-31:

26. And he blessed his Creator who had created him in his generation, for He had created him according to His good pleasure; for He knew and perceived that from him would arise the plant of righteousness 1 for the eternal generations, and from him a holy seed, so that it should become like Him who had made all things. 27. And he blessed and rejoiced, and he called the name of this festival the festival of the Lord, a joy acceptable to the Most High God. 28. And we blessed him for ever, and all his seed after him throughout all the generations of the earth, because he celebrated this festival in its season, according to the testimony of the heavenly tables. 29. For this reason it is ordained on the heavenly tables concerning Israel, that they shall celebrate the feast of tabernacles seven days with joy, in the seventh month, acceptable before the Lord--a statute for ever throughout their generations every year. 30. And to this there is no limit of days; for it is ordained for ever regarding Israel that they should celebrate it and dwell in booths, and set wreaths upon their heads, and take leafy boughs, and willows from the brook. 31. And Abraham took branches of palm trees, and the fruit of goodly trees, and every day going round the altar with the branches seven times.

Interestingly, Jubilees names Jerusalem as God's chosen place, which the Torah didn't.

Precisely because it parallels yet differs with the Torah (in many cases being "stricter") Zeitlkin believes that it was intended to replace the Torah.

Here are Zeitlin's conclusions (click to enlarge them):


Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Walk like an Egyptian

Steg calls attention to an interesting midrash, שמות רבה כב:א:

When the kingdoms would be allegorized, they would be compared to animals, and when the מצרים would be allegorized, they would be compared specifically to foxes —Rabbí El‘azar beRabbí Shim‘on said: the מצרים were tricky, therefore they were compared to foxes; and just as foxes walk while looking backwards, so too do the מצרים walk while looking backwards.

Steg points out that images of animals and humans from Egyptian hieroglyphics show them facing backward (over their shoulder, like an owl) and supplies this image:


Could be. I'm not so sure this is precisely what is intended because with a little checking it doesn't seem like human figures are always facing backward in Egyptian hieroglyphs.

However, the sort of stiffness of the human depictions in Egyptian art have long been noted, like this:



Indeed, such postures are a part of popular culture.

I believe Steg gave a beautiful explanation for the factual, historical basis of this midrash, although I think that perhaps it is a more general allusion to type of Egyptian depictions in reliefs which we are used to, rather than hieroglyphs specifically.

Or, maybe they did walk backwards!

Monday, June 11, 2007

The other Mordechai Breuer, 1918-2007

R. Prof. Mordechai Breuer z"l.

More than five words can say here

Examining the Artscroll phenomenon (on diversity, illusion of).

At What's Bothering Artscroll? I posted the full text of the interesting Jewish Press interview with R.*Nosson Scherman. I posted it mainly for posterity, since I don't know if the Jewish Press archives will always hold it. I didn't have the chance to highlight excerpts which I found interesting and worth comment; besides, R. Maryles already got to some of it.

So I thought it might be interesting to discuss another angle of the Artscroll question, namely that its critics maintain that it presents a particular Jewish hashkafah using selections from a wide (but somewhat resticted) range of classic Jewish sources without giving a true picture of the views of these sources (save, perhaps in works dedicated to one specific person, e.g., their multi-volume translation of Ramban's commentary to the Torah) and subsequently without revealing for the uninitiated that the corporate hashkafah may or may not be shared in part or in whole by the sources it quotes--certainly allowing for the impression that it does. What I mean by that, is that one may form the impression that sources ranging from R. Avraham Ibn Ezra to R. Wolf Heidenheim essentially share the general Artscroll hashkafah given that the only comments cited by these figures are of the sort that form the potpourri of views.

Here is the question and answer:

Some people claim that ArtScroll does not quote rabbis from certain camps in their works. For instance, I’ve heard complaints in Chabad circles that the Lubavitcher Rebbeisn’t quoted. The same could probably be said about Rav Kook. How do you respond?

"Authors will quote, first of all, classic sources, which almost by definition excludes almost anybody in the 20th century. My commentary on Chumash relies mostly on classic sources, and some moderns. Rav Soloveitchik is quoted there, as are Rav Kotler, Rav Feinstein and Rav Schorr. But if it’s my commentary, then I’m going to write it according to what I learned and my style of learning and how I understand it, and I’ll quote my teachers.


"There are a lot of great men who are not quoted. Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzenski was the gadol hador and I don’t think he’s quoted anywhere in the Chumash or Tanach. Neither is the Satmar Rav. The idea is that the person who’s learning it should understand the content. It’s not a question of trying to include as many names as you can for the sake of popularity. It’s a matter of trying to clarify the material."

The text I put in red is the most cogent answer I could possibly think of. Indeed, Artscroll's weltanschauung is that of their writers and contributers. Why on earth should it be anyone else's?

But this begs two questions.

One, certainly Nosson Scherman should be expected to present his teachers and his style of learning and not other's teachers and other styles of learning. But if Artscroll respects the legitimacy of other teachers and styles of learning, why isn't its oeuvre more diverse by the simple method of hiring a more diverse team of writers? In other words, I could understand if its team of mainstream sort-of-centrist yeshivishe writers would output mainstream sort-of-centrist yeshivishe product. But why should all of their writers have that background when there are other legitimate teachers and other legitimate styles to be taught?

The second is that the rest of the comment seems to negate this contention. Why then is R. Soloveitchik cited? Was he a forerunner and teacher of Nosson Scherman as were R. Kotler and R. Kamenetsky and R. Shorr? How could one escape the conclusion that R. Soloveitchik was included for some sort of cultural or political reason, and if so, why ought one not conclude that a R. Kook or a Lubavitcher Rebbe were excluded for the same reason?

edit: in relation to this question:

Some companies are $10 million companies, others, $100 million. Is there a number one can pin on ArtScroll?

No, I can’t give you a number on that. But I can say that people think that ArtScroll is a gold mine. It’s not. We have to go out and raise money. It’s very very far from a gold mine. Some books sell very well, but the profits from those books subsidize the other books.

Primarily, though, major works like the Talmud, Ramban, Divrei HaYamim etc. cannot be funded by the market.

It’s no different than a yeshiva, or, l’havdil, Harvard or a symphony orchestra that has to raise money in addition to tuition and ticket sales.


there is an interesting link.

*Now that R. Marcus Lehman is "Lehman," TRFKA R. Scherman may as well be Nosson Scherman.

Sunday, June 10, 2007

Interview with Nosson Scherman

'Our Goal Is To Increase Torah Learning' By: Elliot Resnick, Jewish Press Staff Reporter Wednesday, June 6, 2007

An Interview With ArtScroll's Rabbi Nosson Scherman

ArtScroll, an imprint of Mesorah Publications, is a phenomenal success story. In almost every Jewish home and synagogue one can find ArtScroll’s biographies, Jewish law books, and translations and elucidations of Jewish classics.

According to Rabbi Nosson Scherman, ArtScroll’s general editor alongside Rabbi Meir Zlotowitz, ArtScroll has published more than 800,000 siddurim, 400,000 chumashim, and 2,000,000 volumes of Talmud.

In 2004, ArtScroll completed its 73-volume translation and elucidation of the Babylonian Talmud – a project that cost an estimated $21 million.

The Jewish Press recently spoke with Rabbi Scherman about ArtScroll’s accomplishments and some of the criticisms that trail almost every successful endeavor.

The Jewish Press: How do you explain ArtScroll’s success?

Rabbi Scherman: Since the end of World War II, you have had a couple of generations of men and women who went through yeshivas and Bais Yaakovs. They are people who want to learn (as well as many baalei teshuvah who are interested in Yiddishkeit), but English is their first language. Even if they can open a sefer and learn it, it’s an effort. They can’t curl up with it and read it easily.

But here you have something in their own language with a pleasant style and attractive graphics. A lot of serious, curious and sincere people have felt that here finally is a way that enables them to learn.

ArtScroll recently began translating and elucidating Talmud Yerushalmi (the Jerusalem Talmud), which used to be a closed book to most people. What made you decide to undertake the project?

Yerushalmi is very hard to learn. But Yerushalmi is also one of the classics of Torah Yiddishkeit. To say that it’s important is an understatement.

Since we had people talented enough, we felt it was our responsibility to do it. The work is difficult mainly because there’s no Rashi, who is the key to everything. Anyone who worked on the ArtScroll Talmud Bavli will tell you that they went away from it with a much greater appreciation of Rashi than they ever had before.

The first ArtScroll Yerushalmi volume in Hebrew, Maseches Shevi’is [next year is a shmittah year], has recently been published. This is very important because the Yerushalmi Shevi’is is the basis for the laws of shmittah. There is no Talmud Bavli on Maseches Shevi’is.

Does ArtScroll commission projects or do people simply submit manuscripts unsolicited?

Both. When people come to us with a manuscript, if we feel it has merit and will serve the public, then we’ll accept it.

There are books that we did because we felt they were important and we were counseled by gedolim to do them. Divrei HaYamim is probably the best example. We were urged by Rav Yaakov Kamenetzky and Rav Mordechai Gifter, zt"l, to do it because there’s no really good commentary on Divrei HaYamim in any language that discusses the differences between the accounts in Divrei HaYamim and Shmuel and Melachim. And there are many variations.

How did ArtScroll begin?

ArtScroll began in late 1975, when a young man
in his 30’s, a rebbe [teacher] in Toras Emes, Rabbi Mair Fogel, passed away in his sleep. Rabbi Zlotowitz was a close friend of his and wanted to do something in his memory. Since Purim was just a couple of months away, he decided to do a translation and commentary on Megillas Esther and finish it at the shloshim. I was a yeshiva principal – at Yeshiva Karlin Stolin Boro Park – at the time; he asked me if I would edit the work and write an introduction. (We had become acquainted over the years when I helped him with copy for brochures and journals.)

It was supposed to be a one-shot thing, a one volume tribute, period, because Rabbi Zlotowitz had a business and I was a yeshiva principal. But that Megillas Esther turned out to be amazingly popular. I think over 20,000 copies were sold in just a couple of months, from the time of publication until Purim.

And then, roshei yeshiva urged us to continue. So we both continued part time. And then we started doing it full time, and then time and a half.

Where did the name ArtScroll come from?

From Rabbi Zlotowitz’s business, his studio – ArtScroll studios – which did brochures, scrolls used for awards and invitations. "ArtScroll" – because they were artistic scrolls, very beautiful, colorful, with calligraphy. The name stuck.

Some people claim that ArtScroll does not quote rabbis from certain camps in their works. For instance, I’ve heard complaints in Chabad circles that the Lubavitcher Rebbeisn’t quoted. The same could probably be said about Rav Kook. How do you respond?

Authors will quote, first of all, classic sources, which almost by definition excludes almost anybody in the 20th century. My commentary on Chumash relies mostly on classic sources, and some moderns. Rav Soloveitchik is quoted there, as are Rav Kotler, Rav Feinstein and Rav Schorr. But if it’s my commentary, then I’m going to write it according to what I learned and my style of learning and how I understand it, and I’ll quote my teachers.

There are a lot of great men who are not quoted. Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzenski was the gadol hador and I don’t think he’s quoted anywhere in the Chumash or Tanach. Neither is the Satmar Rav. The idea is that the person who’s learning it should understand the content. It’s not a question of trying to include as many names as you can for the sake of popularity. It’s a matter of trying to clarify the material.

How do you respond to critics who accuse ArtScroll biographies of whitewashing history by characterizing great rabbis as saints without faults?

Our goal is to increase Torah learning and yiras shamayim. If somebody can be inspired by a gadol b’yisrael, then let him be inspired. Is it necessary to say that he had shortcomings? Does that help you become a better person? What about lashon hara? You know in today’s world, lashon hara is a mitzvah. Character assassination sells papers. That’s not what Klal Yisrael is all about.

Isn’t it a form of sheker (falsehood), though,
to write a biography and knowingly exclude material?

Why is it sheker to omit lashon hara? It’s not. People say, "Well, why don’t you say that this or that gadol had certain serious character flaws?" So you’re not saying it. Is that sheker? It’s not sheker. Rav Yaakov Kaminetzky once said in a "shmuess" that if you go over to somebody and say, "You know you have a long ugly nose," that doesn’t make you an ish emes [man of truth]. That makes you a rasha [wicked person].

How do you respond to the claim that ArtScroll gemaras make learning too easy?

Well, history answers that. There are thousands upon thousands of people who, if not for ArtScroll, would not have opened a gemara in years. That’s number one.

Number two, there are countless people that come over and tell me they started out using the English side and they ended up learning the Hebrew side.

Now another thing – the notes on the English side refer people to other sources. Rav Elyashiv, shlita, has gone through the notes in several of the Hebrew volumes and he says he finds them invaluable. If somebody is serious about learning, then it’s not going to take away from his effort. It will increase his effort. It will enable him to focus his efforts better and go on to explore the sources we offer for further research.

Rabbi Dr. Marcus Lehman’s books [first published in Germany in the 19th century] are saturated with Jewish themes and values. Some of ArtScroll’s books, on the other hand, sometimes seem almost accidentally Jewish. The characters, names and some other details might be Jewish, but otherwise the story seems largely secular. Can you comment?

There’s a shortage of writers. The Orthodox Jewish public is not that big, the well-educated people are not that many and of the ones who are, how many of them are interested in writing books? Lehman was an exception to the rule. He did marvelous things, but how many Marcus Lehmans were there?

That being said, many of our novels have a real solid Jewish content. What you say is true. Some of them are really good yarns, good stories that have Jewish characters, but, by and large, I think most of them have Jewish themes and Jewish values.

Some companies are $10 million companies, others, $100 million. Is there a number one can pin on ArtScroll?

No, I can’t give you a number on that. But I can say that people think that ArtScroll is a gold mine. It’s not. We have to go out and raise money. It’s very very far from a gold mine. Some books sell very well, but the profits from those books subsidize the other books.

Primarily, though, major works like the Talmud, Ramban, Divrei HaYamim etc. cannot be funded by the market.

It’s no different than a yeshiva, or, l’havdil, Harvard or a symphony orchestra that has to raise money in addition to tuition and ticket sales.

Friday, June 08, 2007

Common ground between those who study rabbinic literture; Salo Baron & R. S.Z. Auerbach on the title "Reb."

Some time ago Eliezer Brodt summarized some interesting parts of Halikhot Shlomo by R. Shlomo Zalman Auerbach in a review at Seforim.

Such as:

At the end of this volume, the editors printed a very interesting piece on the topic of saying
ר' פלוני בן ר' פלוני– specifically the use of the Rabbi appellation – when calling someone up for an aliya at kriyat haTorah. R. Yosef Zechariah Stern writes that one should not say the title Reb because it is a problem of גבהות in front of God. R Shlomo Zalman, however, defends this custom at great length as we find everyone uses this title. He explains that the reason for its usage was because there are many different prayer customs that Chazal made to go against the tzedukim (צדוקים) to show that we have the Torah - both written and oral. So too, in the times of the Rishonim, there were people who denied the historicity of torah shebal peh, and these individuals were called Karaites; whereas the more-traditional sect of Jews were called Rabanim, and this is why when we call someone to the Torah we say “Reb” to show that he is not a karaite (Halikhot Shlomo 1:370-373; also included, in short, in the third volume, Halikhot Shlomo 3:33- 34).

This is interesting because it reminded me of the other place where I saw this, namely in Salo W. Baron's fifth volume of Social and Religious History of the Jews (pg. 283).



Just a graphic reminder that there is "one Torah in Israel." Our primary sources are the same, or at least converge, whether a professor at Columbia University or a saintly posek in Jerusalem--and the import and historical content* of these sources are not lost on either.

* Of course it is unclear to me how or if either of them are certain that explanation isn't ex post facto.

Before Vellish,1 before Beit Yosef,2 Before Ari,3... a very old Torah.

Ari posts about a Cairo Genizah fragment from a Torah scroll (from Ex. 13:19-16:1) that may be from the 7th or 8th century that will be displayed at the Israel Museum. Hebrew manuscripts before the 10th century are very rare, with the exception of the Dead Sea Scrolls (which was unknown until 60 years ago). Thus, there is a kind of gap between the 2nd or 3rd century and the 9th and 10th.

Here is an infrared image of part of the fragment--look how beautiful this is!--from שירת הים, from here:



Note the sirtut; note the absence of tajjin (not me'akev) and the form of the letters. So, how do they know it's a Torah scroll and not a chumash? I assume because it is from a scroll and not a codex (bound book), and that lines are scored (sirtut); a law required for Torah scrolls (and tephillin and mezuzot) but not regular books.

Daily Hebrew posts a wonderful visual of what this picture (artfully cropped by Artdaily.com) looks like:



1 Vellish
2 Bet Yosef
3 Ari

Thursday, June 07, 2007

Marc Shapiro challenges Jacob Katz on Daat Torah

Blogging about Daas Torah (defiantly: Da'at Torah) is like shooting fish in a barrel. It's sure to generate 300 comments.

In any case, here is an interesting paragraph written nearly decade ago by Dr. Marc Shapiro in a review in Tradition of "The Uses of Tradition":



Also see my own theory of דעת תורה.

Further reading:

DA'AT TORAH - The Unqualified Authority Claimed for Halachists by Jacob Katz.

Frankly, this topic is starting to be old Manischewitz in old flasks, I admit it.

Hamodia, know what thy Photoshop


Sevenfatcow

Writing a daily newspaper (a lost art).

A fantastic post (from February) at Trailing Technology about what is probably the world's last hand written newspaper!



This Urdu newspaper ("The Musalman") is beautifully handwritten each day, off-set printed, with a circulation of about 20,000.

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

Prof. Shnayer Leiman judges* the new Encyclopedia Judaica

at Seforim.

Abstract: NEJ's omission of most of the original 8000 photographs is a fatal flaw. NEJ includes some good new articles, but fails to update many articles even though there were many important studies on those topics in the past 35 years. Includes errors such as having two entries for the same person with different and contradictory information in each one). NEJ omits entries for figures that--arguably--are more than "borderline" in deserving inclusion,** including many women, rabbinic figures and Judaic scholars. NEJ claims it has to exclude Jewish communities of under 4500, but not only includes one such community but excludes several Jewish communities that almost certainly are greater than 4500. NEJ includes entries for what most would reasonably agree are "borderline" figures.

Bottom line:

"...hold on to your 1972 edition of EJ for dear life! It is not at all clear that NEJ has superseded, or that it will ever supersede, EJ. All public libraries and private collectors will do well to retain their 1972 editions of EJ and keep them precisely on the same shelves they have now occupied for some 35 years."

* Or as he politely calls it "preliminary observations."
** Indeed, I wondered why Rabbi JJ Schachter deserved an entry (he does) but not Rabbi Hershel Schachter of RIETS (although R. JJ S's father R. Hershel Schachter has an entry). see also.

edit: Prof. Jeffrey Woolf reminisces about his experience working for NEJ for six months and advises "DON"T THROW AWAY YOUR EJ!."

Monday, June 04, 2007

פשטות המתחדשים בכל יום; Ethiopian woman.

Rashbam (1085-1185; Tosaphist, Bible commentator, grandson of Rashi) wrote the following in his comment to Genesis 37:2

רבנו שלמה אבי אמי מאיר עיני גולה שפירש תורה נביאים וכתובים נתן לב לפרש פשוטו של מקרא, ואף אני שמואל ב"ר מאיר חתנו זצ"ל נתווכחתי עמו ולפניו והודה לי שאילו היה לו פנאי היה צריך לעשות פרושים אחרים לפי הפשטות המתחדשים בכל יום

Our Rabbi Shlomo, my mother's father, enlightener of Diaspora eyes (i.e, Rashi) who wrote commentaries on Tanakh preferred mainly to explain the literal intention of Scriptures. I, Shmuel son of Rabbi Meir, [Rashi's] son-in-law זצ"ל, held dialogues with him,*and [Rashi] admitted to me that if he had the time he would have authored additional comments explaining the new [literal exegesis] explanations that were occurring to him every day.

*Possibly challenging this or that explanation which Rashi had offered?

If ever there was a "famous Rashbam," this is it.

And justly so. Rashbam was uniquely situated to tell us something about the great master, and we are glad to know this.

Let's consider peshat [exegesis to show authorial intent**] for a moment. It is the case that the Bible has been combed over many times for many a long year by very smart, very exacting, very sensitive exegetes. Although the answers may not always satisfy, most questions seem to have been asked already.

**Of course someone will pipe up and say "Halivni says peshat means 'context.'" I don't see that as a contradiction to the idea that it means authorial intent.

Actually, that may not be true. How can we know if most of the questions to be asked have been asked? Perhaps that just reflects the fact that few original questions are being asked now, but some watershed (a very smart person; a very great discovery; a revolutionary new way of thinking) will show that there are many new questions to be asked and answered! But suppose it is. I certainly find that most Bible issues have been raised or hinted at least once already, which is why in most commentaries there is the possibility of citing earlier explanations.

In any case, it has been my studied observation that many people don't seem to care for a new peshat that has not already been offered or alluded to. They seem suspicious of it, or if not, just skeptical. Consider the two threads at DovBear on the meaning of the enigmatic story of Miriam and Aharon's conversation against Moshe (Num. 12:1-16). The issue: Moshe's wife Tzipporah is described as being from Midian (Ex. 2:21). Here she is called a Cushite (כושית) , but is not named [biblically כוש is probably Ethiopia]. Translators and commentators have long tried to understand what happened here. There were two trends. One assumes that Tzipporah the Midanite was meant and thus seek to explain what כושית means in some sense other than "a Cushite," which is to say, not an Ethiopian. Others assume that is exactly what it means and posit another wife besides Tzipporah from the book of Exodus; a woman from Cush.

Be that as it may, I think the most parsimonious explanation is to bear in mind Habakkuk 3:7 - "The curtains of Cushan were troubled, and the tents of Midian were shaking." In its use of parallelism the prophet equates Cushan (כושן) and Midian. Could כושית just mean "a woman of כושן"? Yes, I think so.

Opening up my JPS Jewish Study Bible (pg. 308) I see a comment (the annotator for Numbers in this volume is Nili S. Fox) :

Two explanations are possible: (1) This reference is to Zipporah, "Cushan" being part of Midian (Hab. 3:7); (2) Moses married a second woman in Egypt, a Nubian (= Cush). The latter is more plausible since Nubia was part of the Egyptian empire and dark-skinnned women were considered beautiful, as reflected in the Targum's rendition of Cushite as "beautiful."

I do not know what justifies the latter as more plausible, since the latter must posit a character that had never been mentioned and comes awfully close to being a Deus ex machina. Either way, I don't know the the origin of this explanation I favor. Since I do not believe I arrived at it independently, nor do I believe that Nili S. Fox was mechadesh it, I will have to confess that I don't know. But I am sure it is not a medieval Jewish explanation,*** nor a medieval (or earlier) Christian one.

In other words, one must note that none of the classic or not-so-classic commentators thought of Hab. 3:7. Although the results of modern philology, archaeology and other kinds of critical study was not available to them, almost every one of them knew the text of the Bible practically, if not literally, by heart. It seems unlikely that this explanation should have eluded all the "very smart, very exacting, very sensitive exegetes" (if I may quote myself)! Ordinarily this should give one pause. One must consider if all those people, or at least some of them, did make the connection but rejected it as a plausible explanation. If so, why? Since all of them are silent while usually at least one of the exegetes will discuss a possibility that they reject, one is inclined to believe that this simply did not occur to any of them. That is, they didn't reject it if they didn't consider it!

Is it possible that the true peshat, the true authorial intent of this little story in the Chumash was not discerned until relatively recently? That seems so farfetched! And yet, the exegetes themselves offer convincing peshat explanations which had not been given and evidently not thought of before their time. Why should there be a cap on original and true (or likely) exegesis? Did not Rashi acknowledge that every day he was refining his understanding of the peshat?

A justly famous example of a success of a modern discipline (archaeology) shedding light on what is almost certainly the correct peshat (authorial intent).

Sure: maybe my preferred explanation here is flawed. But why? Tell me what's wrong with it. Is it that no one seems to have understood it that way until recently? Is it that she should have been called a "Cushanite" instead of "Cushite"? Help me out here.

Edit:***I must confess that I have embarrassed myself. Shortly after posting this it was pointed out to me that Ibn Ezra says this explanation! Clearly this is where I first heard the explanation. Furthermore, it basically invalidates almost the entire post, as I meant to give a practical example of a new explanation which seems correct. In this I failed. However, I will leave this post unedited so as not to alter my own history. Furthermore, some of the issues and questions I raised are still worth pondering.

The pointed text of Rashi's Isaiah is different from ours; also, does Artscroll avoid any textual criticism issues in Tanakh?

Isaiah Chapter 45
כה-אמר יהוה למשיחו לכורש אשר-החזקתי בימינו לרד-לפניו גוים ומתני מלכים אפתח--לפתח לפניו דלתים ושערים לא יסגרו
1 Thus saith the LORD to His anointed, to Cyrus, whose right hand I have holden, to subdue nations before him, and to loose the loins of kings; to open the doors before him, and that the gates may not be shut:


BT Megillah 12a:

דרש רב נחמן בר רב חסדא מאי דכתיב כה אמר ה למשיחו לכורש אשר החזקתי בימינו וכי כורש משיח היה אלא א"ל הקב"ה למשיח קובל אני לך על כורש אני אמרתי הוא יבנה ביתי ויקבץ גליותי והוא אמר מי בכם מכל עמו ויעל

R. Nahman son of R. Hisda gave the following exposition. What is the meaning of the verse, Thus saith the Lord to his anointed to Cyrus, whose right hand I have holden. Now was Cyrus the Messiah? Rather what it means is: The Holy One, blessed be He, said to the Messiah: I have a complaint on thy behalf against Cyrus. I said, He shall build my house and gather my exiles, and he [merely] said, Whosoever there is among you of all his people, let him go up.

(Soncino; whenever I am not delving into the meaning of the text, I prefer to use the Soncino translation rather than attempt my own. It is not perfect, but it is good. It will, in a word, do.)

In other words, the Gemara explains that Cyrus is not called God's annointed ('messiah), rather read "Thus saith the Lord to his annointed" with a colon, rather than a comma.

Rashi comments ad loc.

קובל אני לך כו' -והכי קאמר: כה אמר ה למשיחו לכורש אשר החזקתי בימינו וגוהוא יבנה את ביתי, תרי קראי כתיבי דסמיכי אהדדי, וניקוד טעם מקרא זה מוכיח על דרש זה, שאין לך טעם זרקא במקרא שאין סגול בא אחריו, וכאן ננקד למשיחו בזרקא, ולכורש ננקד במאריך - להפרישו ולנתקו מעם למשיחו

That is, Rashi wants to say that the cantillation, the trope, the טעמים on the words למשיחו לכורש prove this disjunctive reading correct. How so? The trope on למשיחו is a zarka , which are nearly always followed by a segol (anyone who reads the Torah will attest to this). This configuration is conjuctive, that is to say, it connects words. However, in this case the zarka is not followed by a segol . It's followed by a מאריך, that is to say, a mercha , the purpose of which is to disjoin these two words.

This is a wonderful example of how Rashi uses the cantillation in his exegesis; in this case to support the Talmudic explanation of the verse.

Here's the thing: open up an any Tanakh to Isaiah 45:1 and you will not find a zarka mercha () over the words למשיחו לכורש. In fact, you will almost certainly find a zarka munach () pair.

Here is how the famous Second Rabbinic Bible (Mikra'ot Gedolot; Bomberg ed., Venice, 1518) prints it:



(click to enlarge more clearly; courtesy of JNUL)

The modern critical editions of the Bible tend to follow the Leningrad Codex B19a. In that manuscript considered to be a very good Masoretic codex, it looks like this:


and following this are many modern editions, e.g., the Artscroll Tanakh. (More on Artscroll below).

Interestingly, here is the Aleppo Codex:



As you can see, this is neither like Rashi (zarka mercha) or like the Leningrad Codex and the modern editions (zarka munach), rather, it is a pashta followed by a munach: Mar Gavriel corrected me, noting that the symbol that the AC uses for zarka simply resembles the pashta, but is in fact zarka. Thus, the only thing interesting about this image from the AC is the information that it uses a graphic symbol of different appearance from the present norm; it was news to me and perhaps it is news to someone reading. So I may as well leave it. In any case, it's another textual witness to zarka munach () , which is to say our texts, and not Rashi's.

I propose that the graphic similarity between mercha and munach led to different readings reflected in Rashi's comment and in our own.

Interestingly, the note on this piece of Gemara in the Artscroll Schottenstein elucidation of the Talmud says the following:

Rashi proves [R. Nahman bar Hisda's contention that למשיחו לכורש are to be understood separately] by pointing out that the trop (the masoretic cantillations), of the word למשיחו is a zarka, which is generally followed by a word with the trop of segol, which signifies that the words are connected. However, in this verse the word לכורש, which follows למשיחו, does not have a segol. This proves that the two words are not connected.

Indeed, Rashi says this, but Rashi says something else which the commentary doesn't say: Rashi says which trop follows instead--a mercha, rather than a munach which our editions have!

Could it be that Artscroll avoids textual criticism issues in Tanakh like the plague, even an innocuous one?

I thank my grandfather for making me look up the passuk in Isaiah as we learned this Gemara in Megillah many years ago. It was then that I discovered (admittedly with him all but flashing signs in my face prompting me to) that Rashi indeed had a trope symbol here which we do not.

Doktor Hoffmann

For those of you who sprechen sie Deutsch, Dr. David Hoffman's (הרה"ג מהר"ר דוד צבי הופמן זצ"ל) Das Buch Leviticus is entirely available on Google Books. (Also Der Schulchan-aruch und die Rabbinen über das Verhältniss der Juden zu Andersgläubigen, if Gothic script is your speed, and some of his commentaries in Hebrew).

A wonderful biographical sketch by Alexander Marx, his beloved talmid and son-in-law, in the latter's "Essays in Jewish Biography."

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

A positive-historical chumra?

There is a halakhic puzzler. Halakhah requires married women to cover their hair and it is considered a biblical requirement. BT Berakoth 24a: "R. Shesheth said: A woman's hair is a sexual incitement, as it says, Thy hair is as a flock of goats." אמר רב ששת שער באשה ערוה שנא' (שיר השירים ד) שערך כעדר העזים
There is near unanymity that this refers to a married woman. Thus, married woman have to cover their hair, unmarried women--whether 13 33 or 99--don't (never been married, really). I say near unanymity, because there've been communities which required unmarried women to cover their hair as well.

This leads to some puzzlement. If female hair is ערוה, sexual incitement how can it possibly be that this is dependent upon marriage? Clearly this is not a typical sort of ערוה; it obviously isn't like the breasts. So what gives?

The best answers are all apologetic. They amount to some variation that seeing the hair is supposed to be "private for the husband" or perhaps that allowing unmarried women to go bare headed is a concession of sorts (to snare a husband?).

But suppose one takes a positive-historical approach--paranthetically, the 19th century European interpretation of Judaism (or movement) called Positive-Historical Judaism, a term coined by R. Zecharias Frankel, has nothing to do with a positive outlook (as Wikipedia, R. Berel Wein and others understand it (quote to be supplied later). It is true that "positive-historical" sounds like "we like this Judaism thing, but we're going to be historical about it," but it doesn't mean "we like this Judaism thing." It refers to Positivism, a 19th century theory which promotes the belief that only knowledge gained through the application of scientific method is true (or proved true). Okay, I know little about Positivism and hope I didn't botch that up. But that is indeed what Frankel meant. He meant that the kind of Judaism he promoted was to employ the scientific method in the study of its sacred texts, laws and customs. Not "I like Judaism; I feel positive toward it," which of course he did.

In any case, taking a positive-historical approach one might wish to know what באשה in שער באשה ערוה meant at the time it was said by R. Shesheth. In other words, is an "isha" only a married woman? Whether the answer is yes or no, one also would wish to know when were women getting married in R. Shesheth's time? Could it be that then, before the age of delayed adulthood, girls got married at about the onset of adolescence? If so, the passage is explained fairly well. There is no problem of how a 20 year old woman's hair is not ערוה so long as she is not yet married, but once she marries then--overnight--that same hair becomes ערוה. Rather, R. Shesheth is basically saying that much like obviously sexual parts of a woman, hair is also ערוה. By "woman" he may well have meant "married woman," but that might have simply been exactly the same thing as a sexually developing young girl. Which is to say, hair covering is to begin with puberty, more or less.

I know that it will be objected on historical grounds that the Talmud very precisely defines puberty in relation to physical development. If so, then how could "the onset of adolescence" or "the time when girls get married" be meant? Well, I need to think about that. :) In any case, it seems to me that using a positive-historical approach (assuming that the historical evidence bears out my tentative assumption that the time girls got married was at the time of physical development) the halakhic requirement actually called for no discrepancy between women of all ages who didn't marry and those who did. Hair would not "become" ערוה with marriage so much as with physical maturation. Realize also that such young marriage was certainly practiced in medieval Ashkenaz, and even as late as the 19th century in parts of the Jewish world.

It is not unfortunate, I suppose, that if this was the "original intent" that it became forgotten in time until the gap between the onset of when women actually begin covering their hair and when girls actually begin to become women widened. This only meant that now that we delay adulthood (and marriage) our young ladies are not burdened with a burdensome practice that even many adult women find challenging.

(Of course this whole pilpul can probably be undone from a positive-historical perspective by noting that "minhag Lita" was not to cover the hair for about a hundred years. ;)

When Yiddish is not really your native tongue

Fotheringay-Phipps comments (on this post):

I once had an argument with a Yiddish speaker from Lugano (whose other native language was Italian) as to how one described that one feels cold. I said "ich bin kalt" (I am cold) and he insisted that it was "ich hub kalt" (I have cold). We asked an Israeli Yiddish speaker who said it was "es iz mir kalt" (it is cold to me). Of course, all three of us were using the Yiddish translations of the proper expression in our native languages.

No besamim in this rosh

One of the great scandals of the rabbinic scene in the late 18th century was the publication by R. Saul Berlin of the work he titled Besamim Rosh. The work was described as a collection of teshuvot from an unpublished manuscript, the bulk of which were authored by the 13th-14th century rishon R. Asher ben Yehiel, known as the Rosh. If it were so, it would have been a very important work indeed, as the Rosh was one of the greatest halakhic decisors of all. Included with the teshuvot was a commentary by Berlin himself, called Kasa De-harsena (much Besamim Rosh information at the Seforim Blog).

Something was fishy about the work, namely that it discussed the most absurd questions one could think of--indeed, it read like a parody of she-'elot u-teshuvot--and its conclusions were often permissive to the point of suspicion.

For example: within its pages was the claim (#200) that a shohet needs to test the sharpness of his knife by running it across his tongue (interestingly enough, to give a sample of how it has influenced and penetrated what might be called popular Orthodox culture--as a child I heard that a shohet indeed must check the knife by running it [carefully, one guesses] over his tongue!]). But this is nothing. Within its pages the question of whether guests are to feast at a wedding held on Tisha B'Av due to extenuating circumstances, namely, if the bride is in immanent danger of being abducted by a nobleman (#174) or whether a one-armed man should wear tephillin shel yad along with the shel rosh on his forehead (#100). One teshuvah has the Rosh--a proud, staunch opponent of secular learning--lauding it to the sky.

Needless to say it was suspected as a forgery right away; Berlin being accused of forging it. Indeed, although the work was defended by his father--a distinguished rabbi--it sealed Berlin's already sullied reputation (having previously published an anonymous work scathingly attacking R. Rephael Cohen of Altona, Hamburg and Wandsbeck who had led the attack on Mendelssohn's Bi'ur). For his part, Berlin maintained that he most certainly did not forge it! However, with no name to his name he died shortly after the affair in London.

Assuming he did in fact forge it, the question is, why? At the time it was widely assumed that he intended the work as a sort of Trojan Horse within the rabbinic camp. Berlin, it was thought, simply meant to critique the supposed casuistry of halakhah by slipping such a work into its canon (even though a lately discovered work by a rishon would hardly be likely to become authoritative). Berlin was an early closet Reformer. A more charitable reading can be found in Talya Fishman's essay "Forging Jewish Memory: Besamim Rosh and the invention of preemancipation Jewish culture" in the Yosef Hayyim Yerushalmi festschrift. While agreeing that he intended it is a kind of critique of rabbinic culture, she suggests that his intent may not have been as radical as it seems, because there was an accepted practice of inventing hypothetical questions in order to author teshuvot, perhaps because "real" shu"t requires a timely response. Theoretical ones can be researched in much greater depth and with more leisure. In other words, perhaps the "Trojan Horse" model was not true; he never intended the work to compromise actual halakhah deciding. Indeed, the wording of the stranger teshuvot is vague and elusive.

Be that as it may, the work seems to have been cited as a normal halakhic source in subsequent shu"t literature--unaccountably so, many would say. (No one ever accused R. Saul Berlin of not "knowing how to learn.") It isn't as if criticism of it went away. Indeed, the author of Avnei Nezer claims that the only thing to do with the Besamim Rosh is to burn it--on Yom Kippur which is on shabbos! But, as Fishman notes, learned rabbis such as R. Ovadya Yosef quote from it, seemingly treating it as a halakhic work. R. Shlomo Yosef Zevin wrote that it was certainly a forgery, but one may learn from the work--but not the man [Berlin]. R. Kook too quoted the Besamim Rosh, being well aware that it was a forgery (see Rabbi Kook's View of the "Besamim Rosh").

Indeed, it was most surpising (interesting? alarming? amusing?) to find the following in R. J. David Bleich's Contemporary Halakhic Problems Vol. I see here ("A related question is discussed by Teshuvot Besamim Rosh, a work of questionable authenticity commonly attributed to Rabbenu Asher. Besamim Rosh, no. 340, questions..." -- and then devotes two pages discussing it).

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Joshua bin nun (also Paul Kahle, the Qur'an, the Masorah, Israel and Sri Lanka).

When I was a child I came home from yeshiva with a question my rebbe had asked us. Why is Joshua the son of Nun* (יְהוֹשֻׁעַ בִּן-נוּן, typically) called "bin Nun" rather then "ben Nun"? If we gave a good answer we could get a prize.

Dutifully I asked my father and he said he didn't know, but would check. He found that the Ramban (Ex. 33:11) suggested that the name is to be read together as "binnun" (as indicated by the masoretic hyphen) in the sense of בינון, Joshua, "the one with understanding."

My rebbe liked that answer, even though I doubt he believed I looked up the Ramban myself (being perhaps 9 years old).

For more than two decades I have thought about this enigmatic vocalization. Over the years I have collected other suggestions. The Chasam Sofer suggested that when Joshua's name was changed from Hoshea to Yehoshua there were no nekkudot for the yud, (which had been previously part of the name Sarai before a yud was removed and replaced with a heh, making Sarah [BT Sanhedrin 107a]) so two dots were "borrowed" from the segol under the "ben," leaving it with one dot, that is, a hirik. (What about Num. 13: 8 הוֹשֵׁעַ בִּן-נוּן?) Indeed, when I asked a great talmid chochom about the unusual vocalization he began his reply by saying "There is much Torah on this, but it is mostly derush."**

In fact, Joshua is not the only "bin" in Tanakh. Other examples include Deut. 25:2 (וְהָיָה אִם-בִּן הַכּוֹת הָרָשָׁע), Jonah 4:10 (שֶׁבִּן-לַיְלָה הָיָה וּבִן-לַיְלָה אָבָד), and a personal name: Proverbs 30:1 (אָגוּר בִּן-יָקֶה). Furthermore, another talmid chochom pointed out to me that it is possible that Benjamin, בִּנְיָמִין, is another example. Indeed, Rashi (Gen. 35:18) says that the meaning of the name is "son of the south," as in the expression צָפוֹן וְיָמִין, "north and south" (Psalm 89:13) which is to say that it is a contraction of two words. Given the vocalization וְיָמִין, evidently "ben" changes to "bin" in "Binyamin" for ease of pronunciation.

Paranthetically, a note about "ease of pronunciation" is in order. It's important to recognize that languages do funny things for the ease of pronunciation of its native speakers. Not being a native speaker is an impediment to understanding why this occurs. For example, in Hebrew the surrounding vowels determine whether the בגדכפת letters are hard or soft. Thus, you would say "Bereishit" but if you introduce the conjuctive "and," (ו) you would have to say "u-vereishit." This is correct Tiberian Hebrew. If you know the rules then you make the change. But am I wrong in suggesting that almost all of us would have no trouble at all saying "u-bereishit"? That's because the change does not occur to ease our own pronunciation. As non-native speakers of Tiberian Hebrew there is nothing difficult to our own ears and mouths that prevents us from reading it either way. Not so to native speakers who did have this difficulty.

To give a practical example in English. South of India there is a country called Sri Lanka. North of the Sinai desert there is a country called Israel. Americans pronounce "sri" like "shri." Americans pronounce "Israel" like "Izreal." Natives of Sri Lanka pronounce it "ssri," and Israelis pronounce it "Yissrael." Why don't Americans call Sri Lank "Ssri" Lanka? Why don't they call Israel "Issrael?" The answer is because those are too difficult for Americans to pull off. There is no "ss" followed by an "r" in English (which is why all you Srulis out there have to endure "Shruli"). Americans just can't say "Ssri," so they say "Shri." In American English the consonant /s/ is often voiced as if it were a z, depending on the vowels around it. It is difficult for Americans to say "Iss," but not "Iz." As for "ra-el," fuggedaboutit. Are you kidding me? These two syllables go together like oil and water in English (not so Hebrew) so Americans say "real." "Izreal."

But I digress. My point was that evidently--at least it is possible--there is something about the conjunction "Ben-Yamin," Bnymyn, which required "Binyamin" instead of "Benyamin" (seems like we do it fine in English, don't we?). Perhaps this is somehow the case with יְהוֹשֻׁעַ בִּן-נוּן and the other examples.

The aforementioned first talmid chochom who pointed out that most of the "Torah" on the subject is derush noted that "Grammar may be more useful here":

Shen (tooth) and ben (son) are pronounced with a tzere in the absolute state, yet appear as shen (with a segol) and ben (with a segol) in the construct state. In the plural construct, we find shinnei (also: 'et [time] and 'ittei), with a dagesh in the second root letter. One suspects that the double nun in bin-nun acts exacly like the double nun in shinnei.

Awhile ago Steg said something similar. He pointed out that "bin Nun" works as a unit, that is, a geminated (double) nun. He gave an example based on the Hebrew word lêv (heart). In semikhut it is lev and with suffix it becomes libb-. Perhaps it is the same thing with "son." Bên, Ben and Binn-.

Indeed, the masorah combines bin and Nun: bin-Nun (the hyphen indicates that it is to be regarded as one word).

Bottom line: one has to explain the oddity of this and the few other examples. It would be easier to explain if not for the others, particularly the personal name אָגוּר בִּן-יָקֶה in Proverbs!

All this leads one to suspect that one is dealing with an old oral tradition. The question as to what the Tiberian massoretes were doing has been much discussed. Although one is tempted at the outset to assume that they were merely recording traditions, one wonders how indeed there were millions of minute traditions regarding the Biblical text. Furthermore, earlier evidence whether from the Talmud or elsewhere shows that Hebrew was pronounced differently at different times. It is clear that at the same time the Jews of Babylon pronounced Hebrew differently. Thus, it is practically impossible to say that the Tiberians recorded the way the Bible was read from time immemorial in all its exactitude. If so, what were they doing? Were the Tiberians recording their own pronunciation (using old traditions [kri u-kesiv, small letters, etc.]), of course)?

That might seem compelling. Indeed, one of the great Bible scholars of last century, Paul Kahle, believed that the Tiberians were compiling an idealized way of reading the Bible, perhaps modeled on (or at least parallel with) a similar effort for the vocalization of the Qur'an at roughly the same time. Kahle believed that he had proof that the Qur'an was originally consonantal and at a certain point in time it was vocalized according to one way of reading Arabic: the way that the Quraysh tribe of Mecca spoke Arabic (Muhammad was a Qurayshi). This tribe's pronunciation was romanticized as the ideal Arabic, and the consonants of the Qur'an were made to conform with this pronunciation.

An interesting excerpt from Paul Kahle's great (but not infallible) The Cairo Genizah on precisely this subject can be had here: link

Of particular relevance is his view, as follows:





Kahle's view has been justly criticized on the grounds that is is plainly difficult--if not ludicrous--to suggest that the massoretes consciously changed anything. Indeed, they must have done nothing but record what they believed to be the tradition. In cases of doubt they had recourse to solutions, like the halakhic principle of following the majority, of chasing down more authentic (it would seem) traditions, etc. But in the main it would seem difficult to posit an intentional language revolution, as Kahle suggests.

What of the Muslims who, too, should have venerated their Qur'an? If so, how could they have subjected it to modification to conform with the Quraysh pronunciation of Arabic--if indeed this was something more than a minor modification? I would suggest two things. One is that the Muslims did not believe they were dealing with an extremely ancient text with an extremely ancient tradition of pronunciation. Their's was only a couple of centuries old. In contrast, the Jews believed they were dealing with sacred texts that were as much as 2000 years old! Furthermore, at the time the Muslims were in a period marked byijtihad, a sort of interpretive renaissance in which all sorts of Islamic practices, beliefs and traditions were subjected to a process of scrutiny with the aim of establishing authenticity. Such a project would have been par for the course in such a time (believed to have ended at the end of the 10th century). At least as far as we know, no specific parallel occurred among the Jews. Although this period, the time of the Ge'onim, was marked by creativity and even renewal, it was also a period of consolidation, a period where the Talmud was fixed on a pedestal, where the idea of sof hora'ah was fixed. It seems unlikely that in this period the Jews, even an elite in Tiberias, were tinkering with the pronunciation of Hebrew as opposed to recording it, or at least believing that is all they were doing.

In any event, what I think is most plausible is that these fine listeners, these men with sensitive ears, definitely heard "bin Nun (or "binnun") and most certainly not "ben Nun!" That is how it was pronounced. Why did they hear this? What is it's origin? I am still looking...

* The "u" of "Nun" is to be pronounced like the short "oo" in "wood;" "noon," except rhymes with wood and not "afternoon."

** Homiletics.

Monday, May 21, 2007

On the Pinner Talmud: Chasam Sofer, the Czar, Shadal and little known Big Ideas.

Part of the story of the Pinner Talmud is here.

This edition, from 1842, was a translation project undertaken by Dr. Ephraim Moses Pinner (1800-1880), intending to translate the entire Talmud (both Bavli and Yerushalmi) into German. Pinner had been a student of R. Ya'akov of Lissa. He garnered some rabbinic support, and financing from Czar Nicholas I.

Only one volume appeared, Berakhot: "Talmud Babli; Babylonischer Talmud. Tractat Berachoth Segensprüche. Mit deutscher Ubersetzung und den Commentaren Raschi und Tosephoth nebst den verschiedenen Verbesserungen aller früheren Ausgaben. Hinzugefügt sind: Neue Lesarten und Parallelstellen in allen Theilen dieses Tractates und der Commentare, Vokalisation der Mischnah, Interpunktion der Mischnah und Gemara, Raschi und Tosephoth, Etymologie und Uebertragung der fremden Wörter, Erklärungen des Meharschal und Meharscha, R. Ascher mit Erläuterung der Halachah und den abweichenden Lesarten, R. Moscheh's Sohnes R. Maimon's, Commentar zur Mischnah mit Berichtigungen, Einleitung in den Talmud, enthaltend Grundprincipien der Methodologie und Exegetik des Talmud."

In the introduction to this volume he wrote:

"[Nowadays many Jews are unable to study Talmud in the original; those who know it can't teach it] Up to now no one has undertaken to translate the Talmud into the vernacular, and there are even some who have distorted the Talmud and accused the rabbis of saying things they never would have said. Therefore, I have taken upon myself to translate the Talmud into German."

That is, there are two reasons: 1) to open the Talmud to Jews and 2) to counter hostile non-Jewish mis-impressions about the Talmud.

What of the Czar's support? According to Adam Mintz (from whom much of this information was drawn) he supported the translation for two reasons: 1) at the time he was trying to Russify Russia's Jews via cultural and religious restrictions on the Jews. This included the discouragement of the use of Yiddish and the encouragement of the use of European languages, like German, which was close to Yiddish and therefore a practical replacement. 2) As a real antisemite, Nicholas commissioned a report to understand what's wrong with the Jews. The report issued found that the Talmud was the cause of the refusal of the Jews to assimilate into Russian society. Nicholas felt that exposing the Talmud would ameliorate this problem, and to do so would require translating it into European languages, and he was prepared to pay handsomely for such translations.

Thus, Pinner planned to use Nicholas and Nicholas planned to use Pinner. Nicholas purchased 100 volumes of Pinner's translation, and so when it was printed, it was dedicated to him! In addition to Nicholas, there were about a thousand subscribers, including Kings Frederick Wilhelm IV of Prussia, Wilhelm I of Holland, Leopold of Belgium and Frederick IV of Denmark.

At the beginning of the volume were 18 haskamot from both traditional rabbis and maskilim. The volume itself was evidently aesthetically pleasing. It included the traditional layout with German translation on the facing pages. In addition, punctuation was supplied for Rashi and Tosafos. At the bottom of each page he included a translation and etymology of selected difficult words.

When Pinner tried to acquire a haskamah from the Chasam Sofer, the latter was incredulous on the grounds that a vernacular translation is basically impossible given that the plain understanding of Rashi alone is subject to many disagreements, so how could anyone think they could manage such a translation? Pinner assured him that he didn't mean that he would do the whole thing himself, rather he would have a team and he would be the editor. One of the rabbis who would serve as translators was R. Nathan Adler (then rabbi of Hanover; later Chief Rabbi of Great Britain). Pinner claimed that he had lined up R. Adler to translate Eruvin and Yevamos. The Chasam Sofer accepted this, and wrote a haskamah.

As it turned out, Pinner had been playing loose with the truth. Pinner used R. Adler's name to receive this haskamah, and then used the Chasam Sofer's haskamah to get more. Apparently R. Adler denied any involvement at all. When the Chasam Sofer found out, he retracted his haskamah. Not only that, when it became known that Pinner continued to use the haskamah, Chasam Sofer issues a kol koreh asking rabbis to ban the printing, buying and reading of the work.

Shadal too did not offer a haskamah on similar grounds (his letter on the matter was printed in Keren Hemed 2 (1836) pp. 174-182. In addition to highlighting certain errors he felt Pinner had made he questioned whether one man could indeed translate the entire Talmud, noting that even Rashi could not complete his commentary on the Talmud.

Interestingly enough, another objection to the work arose in some quarters, best exemplified by a letter written to the Chasam Sofer by a Dutch rabbi, Tzvi Hirsch Lehrin. In it he noted that if there had been so much opposition to Mendelssohn's Bible, which was only a translation into German with Hebrew letters, how much more so must there be something faulty with a Talmud translated into German with German letters! In addition, argued R. Lehrer, although Pinner might have been motivated le-shem shamayim, to defend the honor of the Talmud before detractors, the opposite would occur once its contents were accessible: opponents would use it to denigrate the Sages, noting that a classic denigration of Talmudic Judaism by wayward Jews is the case of the egg laid on a holiday, deemed irrelevant. How much more so would non-Jewish opponents of the Talmud use this translation against it!

Interesting as well is that this was not the Chasam Sofer's objection.

Ultimately the Czar discovered his true motive and support was withdrawn, which was why only Berakhot ever appeared.

So on what basis can this post, about an aborted German Talmud be an English Hebraica post?

On this basis: I discovered a very interesting review of this edition from 1848, by one William Ayerst (1803-1883), in a book called The Jews of the Nineteenth Century: A Collection of Essays, Reviews, and Historical Notices.

Here it is:








Much of the information in this post was gleaned from "The Talmud in Translation," by Adam Mintz in "Printing the Talmud: From Bomberg to Schottenstein" and the Encylopedia Judaica article, "Pinner, Moses Ephraim."

What do the Chasam Sofer, Shadal and Czar Nicholas I have in common?

My latest post at English Hebraica.

To write a rabbinical biography:

From Joseph Davis's Yom-Tov Lipman Heller: Portrait of a Seventeenth-Century Rabbi:

"A rabbinical biography should not be merely a summary of a few talmudic decisions supplemented by a small assortment of biographical facts. It must present a balanced and rounded view of the subject's life, placing him in the context of a time, a place, and a community. It should follow the subject's development from youth to age, presenting his ambitions and his failures as well as his accomplishments. It should seek to explain the motives of his major decisions--his unconscious motives, if possible, as well as his conscious justifications. It should attempt to see the events of the subject's life from his own point of view, as well as from the author's. The lives of most of the great rabbis of the past, on account of the limitations of existing records, cannot be written in such an extensive and satisfactory way, but Heller's, as I have suggested, can be, and that has been my aim."

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Using Artscroll as a historical source

Learn about the קָמַץ kamatz at What's Bothering Artscroll?

No ifs, ands or buts: Valuable witness to American Hebrew pronunciation in the Schottenstein shas, concering the קָמַץ kamatz.

There is an interesting series of notes in the commentary to the Schottenstein Edition of Nedarim vol. I (37b3) concerning matters of vocalization and cantillation.

Note 27 discusses the function of the matres lectiones, the Hebrew consonants which double as long vowels (א, ה, ו, י). An example given is how a ו shows the חולם is to be pronounced in a word (חוֹלָם; with an"o" as in "home"), for without it the word חם is ambiguous.

Artscroll gives a delicious example of American Ashkenazic Hebrew (I don't know if the term exists, but the concept surely does). It's explanation of how a קָמַץ (qomats) sounds is '"u" as in "but."'

This is completely correct in that it is precisely how many (by no means all) American Ashkenazim pronounce the קָמַץ. But this is not exactly the way this vowel was pronounced by the various Ashkenazic ethnic groups. Putting aside what has survived as the Chassidic pronunciation (oo as in boot; a normal sound shift), this "u" as in "but" most closely resembles--but is not identical with--the German "o." Other pronunciations of the were קָמַץ essentially variations on this theme, some more pronounced, some less, some closer to "o" as in "home" and some almost like "aw" (as in "shucks!"). Then there is, of course, the Temani pronunciation of the קָמַץ which famously resembles the Ashkenazic, each being me'id on the other. And last but not least, the affectation of some yeshivishe pronunciations which simply can't be produced in any notation I am familiar with.

In short, probably most קָמַץ-pronouncers today do say it like "but," myself included. בָּט this is under the influence of American English phonemes, just as the German Jews sounded theirs under the influence of the German "o."

It is noteworthy, by the way, that in Artscroll's serious scholarly work like the Schottenstein it eschews nonsense like it's constructed Hebrew pronunciation.

Surely a historian of 20th-21st century American Jewry will one day use this valuable footnote to reconstruct the Ashkenazic Hebrew, although he or she will obviously have to be sure about how precisely "but" was pronounced in American English.

Punic points: Did a Punic inscription tell of the flight of Canaanites in advance of Joshua bn Nun?

One of my best commenters, R Berel "The Yerushalmi (Sheviis 6:1, 36c) records a tradition that when Yehoshua came to conquer the land he gave the inhabitants the choice of war or leaving and one nation (Girgashi) "believed in Hashem" and left for Afriki."

"I wonder if this in some way reflects a tradition about the Punics.
"

This called to mind Tosefta Shabbos 8, 12:

י[ר"ש בן גמליאל] אומר אין לך בכל עממין מתון יותר מאמוריים וכן מצינו שהאמינו במקום [דגלו] לאפריקי ונתן להם המקום ארץ שיפה כארצם והיתה א"י [נקרית] על שמן:י

(I am not a textual expert, so I am not going to try to make sense of the brackets!)

This in turn called to mind a future post I was planning, about an alleged Punic inscription mentioned by the 6th century Byzantine historian Procopius which was said to have been made by Phoenicians who had fled Canaan long before and, he said, could be seen in his time.

We have it in Greek translation, and it read: ημεις εσμεν οι φευγοντες απο προσωπου Ιησου του ληστου υιου Ναυη. Which does indeed means something like "We are those who fled before the face of Joshua, the robber, the son of Nun."

Not that I need to tell you, but it's good for posterity, in the Latin alphabet ληστου is listoi--ליסטא.

Of course a testimonial from the 6th century doesn't tell us if this inscription is authentic. Indeed, by the 6th century Christianity had spread the story of the Bible far and wide, and the inscription--if it existed--could have been a fraud intended to corroborate the Bible (or it is authentic and ancient). But what it does tell us is that this idea, found in our rabbinic sources, was not only in Jewish sources but was widespread.

It seems the Canaanite provenance of the Punics was not only widely known but an issue vis a vis relations with Jews.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails
'